Monday, September 15, 2008

The shipman's Tale

Interesting Story but it is sad , i mean very sad that the Monk got away unpunished for what he did.Sir John really took the friendship for granted and betrayed not on his friend and cousin the merchant, but also reinforced the common fear of people putting their trusts in Monks.Well i guess that is the beauty of this writing.It gives the readers the choice to really be their own judges.I think think that the merchant's wife managed well to hide the truth from her husband.Sad but that is what is happening in everyday.I think that the morality here is : be careful who you trust and if you really can don't have a Monk as a friend.

Saturday, September 13, 2008

The Wife of Bath

I don't know if it is just me but does anyone think that we are a little too forgiving of the knight? I mean he did commit rape. Maybe Chaucer is guiding our sympathies like he did with Allison and John, but I just felt that he was let off too easy. At the end of the tale we look upon him as a man who learned a lesson about woman and lives happily ever after, yet to me he still did something unforgivable, even though Chaucer doesn't demean him with words.

Wife of Bath - generalization

I think Chaucer's Wife of Bath is an example of Chaucer's analytical methods. She says her own experiences are enough to tell her what it true about marriage. Chaucer brings in characters from all ends of society to explain different aspects that the Church might not understand, even though they have issued edicts and rules. A closer look at each character through the circumstances they live in allows us to gain a greater understanding of the lives of society and sympathize with those characters we may at first glance shun.

Pardoner's Tale Continued

I actually think that the pardoner's repetition of "greed is the root of all evil" is his way of waving his own corruption away. It's the equivalent of someone holding a lit cigarette and, after taking a drag, saying "smoking kills".

I also think that pardoner is similar in character to the friar, although I am not sure which of those two is the worse (we'll probably discuss that in class).

Pardoner's Tale

I think the most interesting parts of the pardoner's tale are the beginning (where he details the sins of gluttony, gambling, and swearing oaths) and the end (where he is called out as a fraud by the host himself).

It is true that we can see something of the speaker's character as each tells their tale, and the pardoner is no exception. He is corrupt and so are the characters in his tale. I thought it was very funny that the pardoner promises to tell a moral tale...and then at the end of the tale, he disregards the moral!

I disagree with the previous post: I think the moral of the story (and the message given by the description of the pardoner's lifestyle) is that appearances can be deceiving - those you would expect to be trustworthy (such as a pardoner, with the Pope's support) are not necessarily so: to err is human, and everyone, clergy or not, is human.

Thursday, September 11, 2008

The Pardoner's Tale

From the beginning, Chaucer begins his novel with each tale consisting of corrupt characters. I liked the Pardoner's tale and how the men who plotted against one another (friends, no less) wanted to be rich. I believe that they each got what they deserved. They had all been drunk and plotted to kill one another. They could have split the money and stayed alive. The Pardoner is a fake and the relics aren't real. He is corrupt and cruel. He would take money from a widow and her starving family than give up his own goods. I was surprised to read that he is actually proud of his corruptness. What I find even funnier is the fact that he had already admitted to the others that his relics are not real, and yet, he still asks for money from others to see them. All these are faults he displays. I agree with the saying "Greed is the root of evil". This describes both the Pardoner and the characters in his tale.

have you guys read the Man of the Law's Tales?

Amazing! i really believe this is the best tale so far. I have read couple tales and i got to admit that ,most revolve sex and good laughs.In this specific tale,Chaucer has really shown grief, sorrow, betrayal, and the power of destiny thought the man of Law's Tale. we got acquaintance with so many characters in this Tale.Constance,the main character, The Emperor her father, The Sultan her first husband,Maurice her son just to name couple .
Chaucer has put the pressure in the reader thought out the character of Constance until the end of this tales .because no one could predict the magic ending of this Tales.
I have to say that the morality of this tale is
JUST LIVE YOUR LIFE BECAUSE YOU HAVE NO CONTROL OF YOUR DESTINY.