Tuesday, September 30, 2008

Ophelia, the maddest one of all?

To me, Ophelia seems to be the "maddest" character in the play.
But first, questions.

Did Ophelia really go mad or is this her grief talking?
Is she even crazy due to grief or did she go crazy from Hamlet's back and forthness on whether he loves her or not. I always thought that this reason is also logical and reasonable.

I also do not understand what in the world she is singing or why she is singing it. Is it solely because she has gone mad that she sings or is there a deeper message?

I also am not sure whether Ophelia committed suicide or not, because the Queen stated that the weight of her dress pulled her down when she laid into the water. Which to me, makes sense, because Im sure dresses those days were HEAVY and had LOTS of fabric. So perhaps in her madness, she went into the water and then inadvertently died.

Thoughts?

!!!!!! Act 4 Hamlet: Poor Ophélia!!!

This act is very emotional because we have different ways of dealing death.First of all let's start with Hamlet. When he was told that his Father was murdered, indeed cried loud that he wanted to do justice to his father soul.He therefore waisting every body time paying attention to his little world and up to this point he has not done anything but murdered the innocent Polonius.They thought he was crazy, and but he knew what he was doing.I really can not believe he waisted all my reading time,while i was expecting he to be his father's son you a warrior.
Then we have Ophélia, poor innocent girl ,i guess was so affected by her father's death that committed suicide.Well i can understand that in a way because king did not do anything to do Justice to her father. Here we can say that she was the crazy one. Instead of Hamlet.
In addition to that we have LAERTES who seems to have what i call the courage to really step up at this point to avenge his father.
In all scene ,the real " evil doer" is the king.He is really setting up a fight between LAERTES and HAMLET so that he might get rid of both of them.

Monday, September 29, 2008

!!!!! Hamlet act 3!!!!!!!!!

Well Hamlet finally set the play to trap the murderer of his fother.He need Horatio help have a closer look to the king body language as the play goes on.In the middle of the play, probably feeling guilty, The King got mad and walked away. I also want to point out that Hamlet did hold his own when he got setted up to find out whether his love for Ophélia was the source of his misbehaving. I felt bad for Polonius who was accidentally murdered by Hamlet.At the same time you could not see any sorrow in hamlet eyes after his criminal act.I would be understanding if he had murdered the king but instead murdered the innocent Polonius.Don't get me wrong Polonius himself was not as innocent as he was making it believe.I would just say he was doing his job
My sympathy for Hamlet took a hit because his is just a guilty as his father murderer at this point.

Gertrude

I don't know about how anyone else feels, but I find Gertrude highly irritating. She seems like such a weak woman and I think the way she speaks to Hamlet is not very motherly. I never admired her for deciding to marry Claudius so soon after her husband's death, and admired her less because she believed Hamlet should get over his father's death. She willingly believes her son to be mad at doesn't seem to care. She also lets Claudius send him away and even though she didn't know he planned to have Hamlet murdered, I don't believe she should have been so quick to get rid of her son instead of trying to help him through his grief. To me she just seems like a weak and uncaring woman.

Sunday, September 28, 2008

Reflection on Hamlet

The way we were talking about how movies make us cry more than real life is actually something I also used to think about. I think music is such a huge part of it and completely controls how it wishes you to respond to a scene or a moment. But if Hamlet considers movies or plays for this matter fake and not real how can he possibly defend living in his head with his thoughts as real?

Wednesday, September 24, 2008

Hamlet - What's behind the mask?

I find it interesting that Hamlet is seen as the "bad guy" in Elsinore. (according to the royal family) A tragedy has occured, the queen has quickly remarried and no one seems to object or suspect foul play. The only sane character seems to be Hamlet. Hamelt is living amongst liars and has no where to turn. All of a sudden the ghost of his father appears, he vows revenge and becomes crazy. Perhaps Shakespeare is showing us the irony of the situation. The innocent are guilty and the guilty are innocent.

Hamelt's rage is very hard to understand. He seems cowardly, but has a murderous facade. Hamlet might be teaching us that our outer facades will eventually reveal our inner motives, our innner faults. He might act crazy but he really doesn't have the courage to kill his uncle, so he waits and seeks proof.

Hamlet Act 3

In this act, Polonius dies and Hamlet succeeds in making his mother realize just what she's been doing since King Hamlet died.
A couple of things confuse me though.

In the beginning of the Act, Hamlet refuses Ophelia's love and claims he never loved her. Later, towards the end of the Act, the interaction between Hamlet and Ophelia seems almost friendly and "normal"... Hamlet is acting much nicer to her here than he did in the previous scene with her. What's up with the change of heart? Or mind?

Also, we know that several of Hamlets friends in the beginning of the play were able to see the ghost. But Gertrude can't. Why?

Hamlet act 2

I really dont blame Hamlet for being undecided about what to do with the ghost's information. Number one he doesnt even know if what the ghost said is true. Two, its not easy to murder someone! Hamlet hesitates about wheather or not to kill his uncle. I actually think he is very smart. He comes up with a great idea to confirm what his uncle has done. He decides to catch the conscience of the king. He directs a play of a murder doing excatly what his uncle has done.

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

Nietzsche on Hamlet

"The Dionysian man resembles Hamlet: both have once looked truly into the essence of things, they have gained knowledge, and nausea inhibits action; for their action could not change anything in the eternal nature of things; they feel it to be ridiculous or humiliating that they should be asked to set right a world that is out of joint. Knowledge kills action; action requires the veils of illusion: that is the doctrine of Hamlet, not that cheap wisdom of Jack the Dreamer who reflects too much and, as it were, from an excess of possibilities does not get round to action. Not reflection, no -- true knowledge, an insight into the horrible truth, outweighs any motive for action." Nietzsche, Birth of Tragedy

Hamlet, act2

Hamlet started to act crazy and Polonius thinks that he gone crazy for Ophelia. But I think that Hamlet started acting crazy because he don't know if he should really kill his uncle for killing his father. I also think that Hamlet is scared to kill his uncle because at the end of act 2 he made the actors perform how his uncle killed his father. He believes that guilty people watching a play have been so affected by the artistry of the scene that they are driven to confess their crimes out loud. So I think that he wants his uncle to confess his crimes where Hamlet would not have to do a crime like his uncle. Maybe then his uncle will get arrested or killed for his crime by the courts order.

Hamlet, Act 1 scene 3

I feel that the way they look upon society on marriage or who you talk to is wrong. As you may know Hamlet and Ophelia like each other but in their society it would be pointless to go further in their relationship. Her father and her brother don't want her to believe in Hamlets words of what he told her about liking her. They believe this because do to the fact that Hamlet live a life of belonging to a royal family, and his intentions don't matter that much and he's a slave to his family obligations. He can't simply make personal choices for himself the way common people can, since the whole country depends on what he does. His choice has to agree with what the nation wants. Since Ophelia does live in the royal life she cannot follow where her heart tells her to go and that would be Hamlet.

Hamlet, act 1 scene 2

I'm not sure about this but does Hamlet want to comment suicide to the fact that his mother married his uncle only after 2 months? If it was after a year or more would he still be this upset due to that during this time it was okay to marry in your family?

the wife of bath's tale

I feel that she had to many husbands in her life time. But I don't think it was wrong of her to have 5 husbands. The men make it seem like she is evil and the church think of it as a sin that she have so many husbands. But what I don't understand is that its okay if a men should cheat or have more wives. If a man can do it so could a women because its their life. I think she made a good point about the church, on how the church tells you about marriage but they have no experience because they can't get married.

hamlet act 2

i too read hamlet in high school and it was interesting to look further into hamlet and his personality. he was struggling with all these changes and was depressed about life in general. it is not too hard to believe because if you do the same thing to any kid today, they would have the same reaction, it is impossible to be forced into a situation like that without feeling some sort of pang. the language used with hamlet describes how he is feeling perfectly, because he is, in a sense confused and shocked and depressed all at once, thus causing his feel for vengeance!

Hamlet__Act II

I was very connected with Hamlet's speech about the perception of the world. And he is right about how we think of the world we live in largely depends on our mood. It is a shame though that sometimes we don't fully appriciate the beauty of nature and life itself. We are too focused on on our daily tasks, rushing from places to places, and hardly communicating with our other people. Of course, there are exceptions, but for the most part, especially in a capitalist society such as the United States, time is crucial and there is always something to do. For people who feel like Hamlet does in this act is even more understandable. Loosing someone very special and having people around you who don't care as much as you do is even harder to 'get over' or deal with, especially when you feel conflicted, confused, depressed and feel as though your world has ended. I've been there, Hamlet.

Class Discussionn of Hamlet..

I too enjoyed yesterdays discussion of Hamlet.  I have read Hamlet a few times, and never really thought too deeply into the his inaction.  I think it is too easy in thnking that a tru warrior would jump to vengance. I lean towards his inaction and maybe even fear as being reflective of his humanity.  Hamlet is not his father, and his situation should be thought through prior to just acting.  I dont know for some reason when I left the class I left with a feeling that we had painted him as a punk, I however would not go that far... I would go with maybe he is just not a hero...yet.

Monday, September 22, 2008

Hamlet

I read Hamlet in High School and I don't remember if his mother knew what Claudius did. I don't think she did but I wonder if she knew his plot would she have supported him, since she clearly had liked Claudius for some time before the King died. Also I feel like a lot of the vengeance is directed at Claudius for murdering Hamlet Sr. but there isn't enough emphasis on how awful his mother is besides for Hamlet being upset and depressed about it.

Hamlet

I found our class discussion very interesting today. I always found Hamlet's lack of action almost amusing, but after thinking over his depression, I find it sad how he feels so stuck. Previous conversations pertaining to Hamlet usually centered around him being a pitiful and pathetic character. However, I believe now that he deserves sympathy. Being in a depression isn't a pleasant situation for anyone and his character could be predisposed to it. Other discussions I've had posed by other teachers is the question of whether or not Hamlet is pretending to be mad or if he really is. Anyone have an opinion on his "madness"?

hamlet and his mother!

Even though I dont know the ending of the play well, I wanted to ask everyone on the blog a question about his character ? Why does it bother Hamlet the fact that his mother got married with the uncle leaving aside the fact that the uncle murdered his father for many motives. Is that she married the uncle for very short period of time after his father death, or is it the fact that he cant accpet the idea of the mother sleeping with someone else other than his father. I think its a deep emotion of his that bothers him inside his character ? I want to know what you guys think?

!!!!!!!!Act 2 hamlet!!!!!!!!

The king and the queen are willing to try everything to make Hamlet forget about his father's death.They brought some of hamlet friends mainly Rosencrantz and Guildenstern to keep him company.It funny how Hamlet could read between the lines .Now he is trying to out play the king by asking one the comedians to tell a story similar to his father's death.He then will be able to observe his uncle body language and see his reaction to the play. Well "revenge is better served cold" i do think that hamlet is rushing a little.If his uncle find out that he knows the truth, he will kill him .

Hamlet

As bad as i feel for Hamlet himself, i am disappointed by the mother's attitude towards her son and dead husband. The way she treats Hamlet is disgusting frankly. How can any mother completely disregard her son's feelings towards his murdered father? She doesn't even seem have the capability to feel such emotions since she doesn't recognize their existence. She and Claudius are so far removed from reality that it is too unrealistic. They feel no sorrow or have any understanding of the situation that they have created, and are looking even more suspicious in everyone's eyes.

Sunday, September 21, 2008

!!!Remaining part of hamlet Act 1!!!

It is amazing how this turned out to be.Hum! this scary way to learn the truth about his father's death.After being informed by Marcelius and Heraltio that his father ghost was appearing to them after his death,Hamlet then decided to go in person confront the ghost and talk to him.

It turned out to be his father's spirit.They then had a conversation where eventually hamlet learned everything about his father's death.His uncle had them believed that the king had died from a snake bite.The truth is that he was poison by his brother now the king and maried his widow.

ok people since Hamlet knows the truth now what is the next thing to do?

Another striking part in this reading is that Laertes in conspiracy with his sister Ophelia is trying to harm Hamlet.Hamlet happened to be in love with Ophelia who is planning to betray hamlet big time.

Saturday, September 20, 2008

Hamlet

I feel so bad for Hamlet. He is being pushed by his uncle and mother to get over his fathers death and at the same time is going through his own pain with his love for Ophelia. He now knows that his uncle is respinsible for his fathers death and is deciding what to do about it. Polonius has ordered Ophelia to stay away from Hamlet and it his causing him great pain and he isnt acting himself. I think that it was nice of his uncle and mother to call his friends to come and try to make him happy. Hamlet being the smart person that he is knows that his friends didnt just show up but rather they were called. Hamlet is also very smart in that he is trying to make his uncle feel guilty for the murder he committed by showing a play that is similar to what he did. Hamlet beleives that he will be reassured from his uncles reaction whether or not he killed the King. This is smart on Hamlets part because he will know for himself and the Claudius wont suspect anything. It is a very sneaky way to find out the truth.

Poor Hamlet!!!!!!!!

After Thursday class, i went back and read the act 1, and i have to point out that i first did not understand much due to the difficulty of reading the text. After paying a closer attention ,in addition to the professor explanations i feel bad for the young Hamlet who had been betrayed by his own mother.It is painful to read the passage where his mother is asking him to get over his father death just after two month.In addition to that ,his confused uncle then, now his dad is asking him to stay with them instead of going back to school at Wittenberg.I t funny and at the same time scary the way him to stay with them.Do i have to recall of the old saying "keep your enemies closer " to predict that the king is trying to harm Hamlet?

Friday, September 19, 2008

Hamlet

I feel sorry for Hamlet because he is not allowed to grieve for his dead father. Most of all he has to sit back and watch his mother and his uncle/step-father in their mockery of a marrage just two months after his father passed. Most of all they have the audacity to make remarks about the fact that he is still mourning his death, and to basically tell him to get over it. To grieve the loss of someone you love is the hardest and most painfull emotions to ever have to go through. It isn't something that you can switch on and off. And how obvious is it to Hamlet that his father's death was not a coincidence.
I think the that Chaucer wanted to show that even though these people played different roles in society, they all had there owe n stories to tell. Most of all they all had some type of baggage. The Pardoner who was supposed to relieve people of their sin was the biggest sinner himself and he had just accepted it. He basically had no conscious or remorse whatsoever.

Thursday, September 18, 2008

Summary of the Canterbury tales- purpose?

Before getting into Hamlet, I would like to talk about looking at all the stories we were required to read from the Canterbury Tales. We have read about infedelity (with a reversal of gender roles), about Allison getting away with it while her suitors were all... suitably punished. We have read about powerful women for their time (the wife of bath and how "differently" she views marriage than a "normal" woman would). We have read about hypocrites and ironies (the Pardoner) and we have read moral stories (greed=death).

My question is... what was the purpose of the Canterbury Tales? Was it a moral series of stories? Was it a way to twist the conventional into something that was different and surprising for its time? Was it about irony, that things will turn up different than we expect?

The types of stories are so vast, I found it difficult to find a common theme.


My comment for Hamlet is that I honestly believe Shakespeare's plays were not meant to be so vigorously studied and interpreted, but enjoyed and to provoke thought in the form its meant to take, as a play. Nonetheless, I shall analyse for the purpose of this class. The characters of Gertrude and Claudius to me, are despicable and not very realistic. Even IF Gertrude lusted for Claudius and wished to remain Queen, and is power hungry, still doesnt explain her lack of understanding that her SON is MOURNING the death of his FATHER and that doing so takes more than a few months. So I find them a bit unrealistic to be so unempathic towards the death of King Hamlet. Did Claudius hate his brother so much that he does not even feel a tiny spark of sadness and regret for the unreversible thing he has done?

Hamlet

Out of all of Shakespeare's works, Hamlet is my favorite. I've read Hamlet numerous times, each time with a different interpretation the characters, although, I've always felt sorry for Hamlet. The readers are compelled to feel empathetic towards him since his uncle murdered his father and his mother remarried Claudius way too soon after the death of her husband. This questions if she ever loved King Hamlet throughout their marriage in the first place. What type of person tells a child that they should no longer mourn their parents death? Both Gertrude and Claudius from the beginning make us question their authority and loyalty to King Hamlet. I also liked the relationship between Ophelia and her brother, and her relationship with Hamlet. I've watched different movies of Hamlet in high school and some of them have still never managed to be exactly like the book. To me this is a very dynamic work that I really enjoyed.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Hamlet Prince of Denmark

We are all given a tragic flaw of choice, choice between good vs. evil, heaven and hell, life and death, reality; Purgatory is the grey entity with the conceptual belief that an individual must correct, or is able to correct mistakes from there past. Both Chaucer and Shakespeare believe in a realm where one is able to repent, or change the quality of life itself. Unlike the knight in the Canterbury Tales we are not perfect, but none the less heroic human beings. To encounter unforeseeable adversity such as ghost, or unpleasant information is to analyze life.

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

Bad Mr. Pardoner

The Pardoner is the most corrupt of all the pilgrims. He preaches about how money is the root to all evil and that greed kills people. His tale is supposed to want people to be better and to make people ask for forgiveness. He should be an inspiration to the people to improve on their behavior to become closer to Gd. Instead of helping these people to become better people he uses the tale to collect money. He takes advantage of innocent people.The pardoner should help people free themselves of sin! If his job is making himself sin how can he relieve others of sin?!!Mr. Pardoner, practice what you preache!
The Pardoners Tale: Trying to Gain Clarity amongst the Confusion

I really enjoyed the complexity of the Pardoners story. This is definitely one story that we need to examine with a closer lens. The pardoner boasts about his insensitivity and greed, then delivers a sermon about the evils of greed then tries to take money from those who know about his fault. The old man reminds me of the old wise sage of a village (or perhaps even one's inner conscience saying, "well if you want to die just follow all the glitter and gold, otherwise stick with me I know how to help remain alive - true to yourself and your moral values". )

The three rioters are searching for death and the old man leads them to it. I think Chaucer is trying to explain how enticing and unforgiving greed is. It literally overtakes and kills the true person. People become unrecognizable by the "disease of greed." I think the pardoner wants to explain to us how absurd greed looks to an outsider and how devastating and addictive it is to the greedy person. The three different sections to the Pardoner's story help us understand the above point. The pardoner is conscious of his fault and what greed did to him, warns anyone thinking of chasing money to avoid it at all costs, and then proves how vulnerable he has become by asking the bartender for money.

The Pardoner's Tale...

I feel the Pardoner's Tale is one of the most realistic human tales I'd ever read in my life. I'd understand that it can be conflicting to one's mind in terms of the way he tells his story. On the one hand, the Pardoner knows he is doing what is considered unethical behavior(s), but he is constantly doing the same things again and again. There is something courageous about it, though. I don't think that someone I know that would be brave enough to tell others all of the unethical things he/she has done or does. I am not saying that he is excused from all of the bad things he does. However, I do feel that he is being 'real' and honest about the things that he does and that probably many others, including church, do as well. This shows all of the kinds of people who are going in pilgrimages!
After yesterday's class discussion, I started to think about one of my classes this semester called Jesus and & the Christian Tradition (Religion 19). One of the main themes within the realm of Christianity is that God created the world in his perfect image and goodness. People then ask the following and logical question: Why are there bad people in this world, then? As the authors of the Gospels in the Bible, including Mark and Paul, say, God's goodness include everything there is in this world (so both good and bad). Therefore, one makes of one's life whatever one wants to make of it based on our choices. Thus, whether the Pardoner's chose to be one of the bad people in this world, he is still part of the diversity and complexity of human nature.

the pardoner's tale

in my opinion, the pardoner is one of the more real characters in which he is trying to persuade the audience that he is out for one thing, when infact, he is the exact opposite. unfortunately, we find people of that nature more now than ever. people walk around preaching different things, when in their own homes, they follow none. the pardoner is just saying what he thinks people want to hear and what gets him the best response, and by doing so, keeps his wallet full. he is 100% immoral and even cruel in what he does, basically stealing money from those who barely can afford it to stash as his own, but unfortunately, those people do exist nowadays!

Monday, September 15, 2008

Pardoner's Tale

I found our class discussion today very interesting. It's disturbing how the Pardoner can preach about greed and yet rob even the most destitute individuals. He seems like a sociopath with no conscience at all. I didn't realize how many intriguing questions could be asked upon reading the tale, and I found the class to be enlightening. The fact that the Pardoner tells a story about the negatives of greed brought up the question of whether or not a greedy person can tell a moral story. In my opinion, anyone can tell a moral story, but if the person telling the story is immoral, the message often doesn't hold any weight. No one wants to be preached to by a person who doesn't practice what they preach. Also, because the Pardoner appears to be boasting about his actions and is essentially a condemned man, makes him seem cruel and evil, in a scary sort of way, in my opinion.

The shipman's Tale

Interesting Story but it is sad , i mean very sad that the Monk got away unpunished for what he did.Sir John really took the friendship for granted and betrayed not on his friend and cousin the merchant, but also reinforced the common fear of people putting their trusts in Monks.Well i guess that is the beauty of this writing.It gives the readers the choice to really be their own judges.I think think that the merchant's wife managed well to hide the truth from her husband.Sad but that is what is happening in everyday.I think that the morality here is : be careful who you trust and if you really can don't have a Monk as a friend.

Saturday, September 13, 2008

The Wife of Bath

I don't know if it is just me but does anyone think that we are a little too forgiving of the knight? I mean he did commit rape. Maybe Chaucer is guiding our sympathies like he did with Allison and John, but I just felt that he was let off too easy. At the end of the tale we look upon him as a man who learned a lesson about woman and lives happily ever after, yet to me he still did something unforgivable, even though Chaucer doesn't demean him with words.

Wife of Bath - generalization

I think Chaucer's Wife of Bath is an example of Chaucer's analytical methods. She says her own experiences are enough to tell her what it true about marriage. Chaucer brings in characters from all ends of society to explain different aspects that the Church might not understand, even though they have issued edicts and rules. A closer look at each character through the circumstances they live in allows us to gain a greater understanding of the lives of society and sympathize with those characters we may at first glance shun.

Pardoner's Tale Continued

I actually think that the pardoner's repetition of "greed is the root of all evil" is his way of waving his own corruption away. It's the equivalent of someone holding a lit cigarette and, after taking a drag, saying "smoking kills".

I also think that pardoner is similar in character to the friar, although I am not sure which of those two is the worse (we'll probably discuss that in class).

Pardoner's Tale

I think the most interesting parts of the pardoner's tale are the beginning (where he details the sins of gluttony, gambling, and swearing oaths) and the end (where he is called out as a fraud by the host himself).

It is true that we can see something of the speaker's character as each tells their tale, and the pardoner is no exception. He is corrupt and so are the characters in his tale. I thought it was very funny that the pardoner promises to tell a moral tale...and then at the end of the tale, he disregards the moral!

I disagree with the previous post: I think the moral of the story (and the message given by the description of the pardoner's lifestyle) is that appearances can be deceiving - those you would expect to be trustworthy (such as a pardoner, with the Pope's support) are not necessarily so: to err is human, and everyone, clergy or not, is human.

Thursday, September 11, 2008

The Pardoner's Tale

From the beginning, Chaucer begins his novel with each tale consisting of corrupt characters. I liked the Pardoner's tale and how the men who plotted against one another (friends, no less) wanted to be rich. I believe that they each got what they deserved. They had all been drunk and plotted to kill one another. They could have split the money and stayed alive. The Pardoner is a fake and the relics aren't real. He is corrupt and cruel. He would take money from a widow and her starving family than give up his own goods. I was surprised to read that he is actually proud of his corruptness. What I find even funnier is the fact that he had already admitted to the others that his relics are not real, and yet, he still asks for money from others to see them. All these are faults he displays. I agree with the saying "Greed is the root of evil". This describes both the Pardoner and the characters in his tale.

have you guys read the Man of the Law's Tales?

Amazing! i really believe this is the best tale so far. I have read couple tales and i got to admit that ,most revolve sex and good laughs.In this specific tale,Chaucer has really shown grief, sorrow, betrayal, and the power of destiny thought the man of Law's Tale. we got acquaintance with so many characters in this Tale.Constance,the main character, The Emperor her father, The Sultan her first husband,Maurice her son just to name couple .
Chaucer has put the pressure in the reader thought out the character of Constance until the end of this tales .because no one could predict the magic ending of this Tales.
I have to say that the morality of this tale is
JUST LIVE YOUR LIFE BECAUSE YOU HAVE NO CONTROL OF YOUR DESTINY.

Wednesday, September 10, 2008

The Wife of Bath's Prolo gue

I think the Wife of Bath brings up many good points in her prologue. I like how she challenges society and the Church with her ideas of marriage and virginity. She works hard to prove her point, which i believe she did very well. At first i thought her forceful tone and eagerness to speak about marriage was an attempt to justify her own actions since had been married 5 times. However, i now understand that she was passionate of her ideas and wanted to get her point of 'embracing life' across, an idea i agree with to the fullest.

The Wife of Bath's Prologue and our discussion in class today really made me think about the boundaries that hold people and society back. For years, society has accepted the rules that we have created for ourselves, like the ones for marriage and sex. It's just interesting to see how we have governed ourselves against things, like sexual urges, something that is so natural and unavoidable.

Miller's Tale- A twist on Convention?

Today's discussion revolving what is and isnt moral, along with who exactly should the audience pity, peaked an interest in me. My opinion, is that (apart from Chaucer's apparent desire to write as many sexually explicit stories as he can, and to create humorous tales), Chaucer created a twist of convention.

It is not the male who was the "player" and "wild" young hormonally-charged adult, but Alison, the woman. Im sure that from those days, and maybe even these days, it is much more likely to find a story where the male is the "player" and the one who gets away with it all. Here, Chaucer changes that and gives Alison this role, which I must say, is pretty refreshing.

After our in-depth class discussion, I have gained new pity for poor Alison, a young woman stuck with an old man she did not love. Not to mention Chaucer hints at the fact that her "natural" nature was of a more frivolous, flirtatious variety.

Thoughts?

Millers Tale

Human beings beauty derives from there imperfection as the harp plays devious, and wicked tunes on an individuals psyche. Or are we willing to accept any message that reinforces are personal beliefs, aspiration, and life? The section that grasped my attention most in the “Millers Tales” was, when Nicholas began deceiving John the carpenter about a flood that would occur. Nicholas manipulated John by using his spiritual belief, similar to Governor Palin said “God wants us to be in Iraq”; Manifest Destiny anyone. But I digress from my point that we listen and focus on what we consider reassuring to maintain ourselves. When in fact we should keep are eyes open when kissing.

Tuesday, September 9, 2008

Canterbury Tales, Penguin

i have to say when i first started reading Canterbury Tales, it was hard to understand. but i like how he had a saying for each person. i have to say it was a good thing that we go over the reading in class because i find it helps me a lot.

"Miller's Tale"

I have to say that the Miller's Tale was a very sad story for the carpenter named John. He was a old man that had a young wife. As you may know his wife cheated on him. She let a another man enter into his home and had sex with him. I felt very bad for him because he loved her and did nothing wrong to her. I didnt like the fact that nothing bad happen to his wife at the end, I would have liked it better if felt stupid at the end and ended up with nobody.

Monday, September 8, 2008

The Miller's Tale

I honestly have to say that the first thing I thought after reading the Miller's Tale, was how bad I felt for the carpenter, John. So he was old and jealous...I don't think he deserved what happened to him at all. I felt dissatisfied because nothing happened to Allison to punish her for her actions. John did however, and I was glad for that because he was a jerk. John seemed to be an innocent victim and ended up with a badly broken arm and ridicule from the townspeople for being crazy.

I also realized, that while the sexual meaning in the prologue was hidden, the Miller's Tale was quite explicit. It seems to me that it might have to do with the fact that it came from the Miller who happened to be drunk while he told his tale, which does not make for a very classy or subtle story.

I look forward to discussing it more in class because I felt so bad for John at the end that my mind focused on that.

A Reflection on Today's Class...

It was a great thing that we went back to our conversation about the portrayal of characters in the prologue today. It was a actually a good transition into talking about the Miller's Tale. As our professor said today, our world is imperfect but it is what makes it interesting. I also think that bad people and good people are supposed to exist to balance our society out. I grew up with the idea that something good comes out of bad things. Thus, even though the Friar was a corrupt Christian, the Summoner was a caring and kind poor man who gave people in society an inspiration to be better. What I like about Chaucer is the way he portrays all of the bad people in society. He does it in a funny and ironic way yet it catches the reader's attention. And, it is because of the complexity (that good or bad people are all part of) of this world that Chaucer is able to write in such an interesting and enjoyable way.

the Miller's Tale

while reading the miller's tale, i was ready to be yet again amazed at the language that the author uses to describe thos story. his use of sexual innuendos is not only confusing, its funny to read these words, knowing that this is taking place years ago. it is somehow satirical as well, especially the branding on the buttox in the end, it sounds like something you would watch nowadays in a cartoon, so the author is here making light of a very dangerous situation. after going over it in class, more and more information comes out, and were digging deeper and deeper into the mind of the author, noticing he has a flare for satire and not telling the whole truth

Saturday, September 6, 2008

Canterbury Tales - The Miller's Tale

I enjoyed the Miller's Tale, and in light of the sexual themes we uncovered in class, the story seemed incredibly graphic. I think the bawdiness of the tale highlights the Miller's lower station (especially in comparison with the Knight, who gets to speak first, and the Monk, who was supposed to speak second.) When the miller insists upon speaking before the Monk, the host is quick to point out that the Monk is a better man - thought this could be a comment on the Miller's inebriation, it also seems likely to reflect the Miller's station in life.

The Miller's tale is hilarious, and though I may be digging too deep, I saw some Christian parallels in the story. Like the prologue, where Chaucer intermingles talk of love and sex with holiness, the Miller's tale has a graphic love story (where Nicholas grabs Alison, thereby seducing her, and they have sex in her husband's bed) and also a Bible parallel (where Nicholas acts as God, commanding John to prepare for the flood, and Absalom acts as Satan, with a fiery brand).

I also thought it was interesting that Absalom - the courteous suitor, who courts properly - is rudely rejected, while Nicholas, the skeevy guy who puts his hands on Alison until she threatens to scream for help, manages to get the girl. What is Chaucer trying to say about love, and about sexuality? Chaucer does not condemn Alison's adultery - and in fact, the story ends with Alison and Nicholas together and John, suffering and ridiculed. Is it because Chaucer is trying to be super radical and challenge the Christian idea that sex should only happen within the bonds of marriage? Or is it because the Miller is narrating and his low-class ideals are shining through his tale? It's pretty clear that the Miller thinks John was stupid for marrying a girl so much younger and prettier, but does that make it okay for Alison to cheat?

Even without looking into the details of the story, the tale seems somewhat Biblical. The story is about a carpenter and his wife...possibly a parallel to Joseph and Mary, since Joseph was also a carpenter. That seems weird to me (and obviously heretical) because if Mary is supposed to parallel Alison then it seems like Chaucer is implying that Mary's "conception" was not immaculate, and actually came from an adulterous relationship. That would make Jesus a bastard and not the son of God, which seems completely inappropriate for Chaucer to have written in his time. How on earth did he get away with writing the Canterbury Tales?!

Friday, September 5, 2008

Canterbury Tales

Just like some others in class, it is my first time reading the Canterbury Tales. I enjoyed reading the prologue and thought it was pleasant, funny, and very enjoyable to learn about the different characters that are along for the journey. However, I failed to read so closely as to identify the possible underlying meanings behind Chaucer's words, as we did in class. I look forward to continuing our discussion in class and to discovering new interpretations.

Canterbury Tales Reflections: The Prologue

Chaucer's novel is written in a poetic narrative. The advantages of this style is that Chaucer can add, criticize and respond to societal issues in a subtle manner. When reading Chaucer's Prologue, each read reveals more information and more content value. I think by using this method Chaucer adds more value and interest to the book. He presents the characters, all different parts of society. By looking closely different aspects of society,at this time are revealed. I enjoy the fact that there is deeper meaning to the Canterbury Tales.

Canterbury Tales

I remember doing part of Canterbury Tales in High School but I was kind of bored with it then. However, when we were in class and our eyes were opened to the sexual connotations in the writing I found that very interesting. It's very cool how you could read something one time, and then after reading between the lines see the same text in two completely different lights. I'm looking forward to seeing what else I did not notice about each of the characters the first time.

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

Canterbury Tales

Chaucer's Canterbury Tales seems very real to me. I feel as though I can relate to the characters. I like the rhythmic tone the author uses. It allows the story to flow. When reading it before today's class, I just read the introductory paragraph without actually taking apart each sentence. After being introduced to the different meaning of what Chaucer is writing, I think that from now on, I will start to try and interpret other books I read. I liked the depiction of each character who is joining the narrator on the pilgrimage. The way Chaucer portrays the characters is very descriptive.
After first reading the prologue in Canterbury Tales, it was interesting to meet all these new characters, some who fit certain stereotypes and some who are just coming in as odd. the set up by the hotel host is interesting because who knows what kind of stories these people can come up with, and seeing how we dug so deep into each word today inclass, i can tell that we are going to find out many more secrets in the tales.

Canterbury Tale Surprise

Reading the Prologue, I can honestly say I was bored. Before I came to class today, all I felt the prologue succeeded in doing was introduce the many characters that we go along the pilgrimage with.
So I was very surprised to find all the sexual connotations we discussed in class. It never occurred to me that "piercing" the root of March and all the spring analogies could be metaphors for fertilization and sex. I guess I took something out of class today.

Writing this way, (Chaucer lived in the 14th century) must have been scandalous back then. I wonder what the reaction to his tales were during his time?
I think that Chaucer, in the beginning of the prologue is writing in a way that the church at that time wouldnt really have a say about it. Kinda like sugar coating his thoughts. It is interesting though, how he uses words to paint his images

The Canterbury Tales...A Question for Reflection.

In the prologue, the author describe the characters in detail. On the back of the book, there is a quote that states: "Now, as I've drunk as draught of corn-ripe ale, by God it stands to reason I can strike...On some good story that you all will like." Is God one of the characters in the story? Or can God be even consider a character in a fictional story?
Caunterbury Tales talks about pilgrims who gather at the Tabart inn that are ready to travel to England. The narrarator is one of the pilgrims who talks about the beginning of spring which makes people want to go on a pilgrimage. 29 pilgrims joined him in the journey. He describes all of the pilgrims with much detail. He describes a doctor, cook, shipman, plowman carpenter and a pardoner. These people are very realistic to me. They debict all the different types of people of a society. There are the people of the upper class (rich, smart ) and the lower class( poor, corrupt).

The Canterbury Tales

The rhythmic tone of sarcasm and realism capture the tone of a hierarchy. As each individual and its status is granted brief moments of success. It Can only make the reader contemplate about life... and life's decision. For it is deemed that with education you are most likely to obtain finical stability. Or you could be a crooked priest who uses his power to his own advantage. But wish to be as well mannered and respected like the squire. The abundant truth of identity, and status, fictitious; but oh so real!
The general prolouge for Chaucer was very interesting. The story was told with a rhyme which made it more enjoyable for me to read. I liked that most of the lines rhymed and that this technique continued throughout the whold prologue. The characters were given vivid and distinct descriptions which allowed me to understand each one more clearly and make disctinctions between the characters. The characters seemed to be realistic as we discussed in class. None of them had any superpowers but were rather regular people living regular everyday lives. The prolouge kept me interested in the book and was a good way to make me want to keep reading.

Tuesday, September 2, 2008

Canterbury Tales Prologue

I've read the Canterbury Tales Prologue in high school and I still enjoy it now. It flows well and I enjoy the rhyme scheme. The characters are varied, each with their own personality and story. In keeping with the subject of realistic and unrealistic characters, those discussed in this story seem to me to be realistic. They aren't perfect and they represent the rich and the poor, the workers and the religious. There is also a lot of irony that can be seen already, as the group is going on a religious pilgrimage and many of them would be considered "sinners." I never got to the storytelling contest, which I find interesting, as it turns the pilgrimage into a business venture so the host can have more customers at his tavern. I look forward to reading more of it and getting a better idea of how people thought during the Middle Ages.