Monday, December 22, 2008
~Happy Holidays~
Happy Holidays everyone.....will probably be seeing many of you in a bar once finals are over! Until then.. Good Luck!!
"Human"
The presentations were so beautiful and inspiring. I am glad that there was such a variety of defining what it meant to be human because it represents the idea that "human" goes beyond some concrete definition. I am also glad that we have all experience something or someone in our lives that has inspired us in one way or another. Everyone did such a wonderful job!
Mrs. Dalloway and regrets
We as human beings will most of the time have regrets when something does not turn out the way we wished them to. Having regrets is not necessarily a bad thing because we are able to learn from our mistakes. And because life is all about choices and experiences, we will make some mistakes. But if we had the chance to go back, would we change all of our mistakes so that we can avoid regrets? If Mrs. Dalloway married Peter instead of Richard, will she not wonder what would life be like with stability? If we go down one road, many of us through our human nature will wonder ..."what if I took the other road?" As for Mrs. Dalloway, in a way I do feel bad for her because her marriage lacks the passion and adventure Peter gave her, but I don't think it means she should have married him instead. She just needs a good marriage counselor or a new husband that will fulfill both the security she needs and the passion she wants.
Douglass
I have always admired Frederick Douglass. he is an inspiration for many who just can't seem to see past their unfortunate situations. First of all, I found it interesting and pretty sad that he had been criticized because he was born a free slave. Just because slavery had been over, does not mean that at that very moment, Blacks were treated equally. He still went through hardships and had obstacles to overcome and was not far from understanding the slave mentality. He lacked an identity like all of the other slaves and had to build something from [having] nothing. Second, his "thank you" to Mr. and Mrs. Auld was one of many areas in his book that touched me. I can understand his gratefulness towards Mrs. Auld for teaching him how to read. On the same note, I found his feelings towards Mr. Auld to be heartfelt. Instead of holding anger for Mr. Auld, he thanks him for giving him the motivation to want to learn how to read. For me, I look at it as, instead of holding hate towards the one who has sought out failure for you, you turn their words around as a way to push yourself into being more than they would ever imagine.
Wordsworth...
I will admit that at first, I had no clue as to what Wordsworth's poem was about. In fact, I began to lose interest as I read along. But after reading it in class, I realized how profound it was and completely out of touch I was. Living in New York City has had both negative and positive effects on me. The negative would be that of not given the opportunity to experience nature the way Wordsworth has. On the other hand, the positive allows me to appreciate nature even more when I do get to go away granting me "life and food for future years" and "tranquil restoration." It is important to have at least something to bring you peace of mind especially when we are part of an environment that has us as pin balls constantly bouncing from one thing to another. His words are absolutely beautiful and touching to say the least. He has a way of digging deep into our minds and building upon an "unremembered pleasure." And the fact that it would mean so much to him (in more ways than one) to pass on this same feeling of lasting pleasure to his sister makes this poem even more heartwarming than it already is.
One of my favorites, "for she can so inform the mind that is within us, so impress with quietness and beauty, and so feed with lofty thoughts that neither evil tongues, rash judgments, nor the sneers of selfish men, nor greetings where no kindness is , nor all the dreary intercourse of daily life, Shall e'er prevail against us, or disturb our cheerful faith, that all which we behold is full of blessings." This is the best gift anyone can receive!
One of my favorites, "for she can so inform the mind that is within us, so impress with quietness and beauty, and so feed with lofty thoughts that neither evil tongues, rash judgments, nor the sneers of selfish men, nor greetings where no kindness is , nor all the dreary intercourse of daily life, Shall e'er prevail against us, or disturb our cheerful faith, that all which we behold is full of blessings." This is the best gift anyone can receive!
Hamlet: Act 2
Hamlet is a sad case. I don't view him as a coward for not wanting to follow through with the ghost's wishes. While it is expected for Hamlet to be angry at the cause of his father's death...do we really expect him to avenge it? We always want to assume that if God forbid anything was to happen to a loved one...we would run out to seek vengeance on the one who hurt them. But at what cost? Would we risk our lives to do so? Though I do not know if I would go as far as acting like I am crazy...I don't think that I would have the strength to physically hurt someone else. Now of course, there are other ways of seeking vengeance. Hamlet's play was a good way for letting out the truth of his uncle's atrocious events.
Spring is in the air....Miller's Tale
Spring is in the air apparently in Miller's tale. First of all, I don't think I will ever look at the word "spring" the same way again. Who knew that is was all about "piercing the root of March" in the prologue. As for the tale, at first Allison struck me as the immoral player but after our in class discussion, I actually felt bad for her (somewhat). While it is wrong to not only cheat on your husband but to deceive him to the extent that she did, she did not deserve to be with someone whom she did not love. I believe that Chaucer in this tale and others presents a flip side to what society would view as moral and immoral. Reading his tales allows us to not see situations in just black and white as I have also viewed John in different ways...sympathetic yet stupid.
Sunday, December 21, 2008
Pardoner: definitely bad....but is he also good?
The Pardoner was also pretty interesting. The Pardoner is one of the worst sinners in Chaucer's tales. One of his lines is, "and lo, sirs, thus I preach. And Jesus Christ, that is our souls' leech, So grant you his pardon to receive, For that is best, I will you not deceive", would have anyone to think that he is after forgiveness and is therefore true to his words. Unfortunately, this is just one of his ploys to suck people into his schemes. The fact that he is aware of what's right and what's wrong and uses Jesus Christ's name in order to deceive others makes him one of the worst sinners. Or is this a way of him wanting forgiveness? When he tells the tale of greed and shows how money can be the root of all evil, it gives the sense of him not just out to hurt others but to warn them of evil. One who is completely evil would not try to warn another of self-destruction. Atleast, I don't think so.
Wife Of Bath
The Wife of Bath was one of my favorite Chaucer tales. "Authority vs. Experience" is the argument for who the Wife of Bath is. She challenges the church's authority and what is acceptable behavior from a woman. While the church might have viewed her five marriages as distasteful and contrary to sacred values, she made the conscious decision of living her life through experience. She made a good point about how the church makes up these rules on marriage yet, for the most part...no nothing of the subject at hand. While it is important to obtain and practice one's values, it is also important to follow your heart and make your own experiences to live and learn from...as what the Wife of Bath did.
While I also enjoyed the tale of the man's journey, I did not feel one bit sorry for him. I don't think it was fair for him to have done what he did, and in the end get to spend his life with a beautiful and loyal wife. I wonder if in those days, how different would it have been for a woman who did something just as worst.
While I also enjoyed the tale of the man's journey, I did not feel one bit sorry for him. I don't think it was fair for him to have done what he did, and in the end get to spend his life with a beautiful and loyal wife. I wonder if in those days, how different would it have been for a woman who did something just as worst.
Carcass
Since I have been mentioning alot about love I felt it appropriate to end off with Baudelaire's poem Carcass. When I first read through this poem I didn't catch that it was meant to be romantic. I know that the person was not comparing the looks of the carcass to his girlfriend or vice versa but it is a very peculiar way to declare your love for someone. It is nice to see that he truly loves his companion but the way in which he went through the description of this carcass to finally tell her was very interesting. I don't think this type of poem would work to win me over. But we must give him credit for doing so in an unorthodox way.
Love = Desire, Desire =Love
I know we were assigned specific poems from Coleridge but I looked up some of his other poems and came across this verse in his poem Desire, "Where true Love burns Desire is Love's pure flame". I think this quote is very profound. I think it explains love in a very enticing and attractive manner. Many people think love is lust but it is not. Lust is more of a craving that is temporary while desire is more of a strong wish which will not go away if true love is in the equation. I think people can lust for something without loving it but you must love something in order to desire and vice versa.
Good vs. Evil
"There is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so" ( Hamlet Act II Sc. II) In saying this Hamlet is giving us an insight into life. Is this statement true? Can there really exist no wrong or right way? Why is it that there are actions or sayings that are proper for some and improper for others? I think it is amazing how common we are as humans in a biological and microscopic level. We all have the same basic needs, we need food, shelter, warmth and water. However, we are all unique and unlike anyone else. But how is it that some things offend some people but not others? How did we get to this point of difference? I think this is a very intriguing quotes because in the end what defines an act or saying as being a bad or good one depends on our definition in life. This reminds me of Emerson because in his essay he says not to be a comformist and to speak whatever it is that we feel we must not worrying about what others say. But should we not respect others space? Shouldn't we try to make others feel comfortable and not say hurtful things to others? Life is full of questions but we all have our own answers to it.
Where art thou Hamlet????
I think Hamlet's story is a very unfortunate and sad one. He seemed like he was a smart guy that could have made better choices but I guess we all cope with things differently. But Hamlet's most famous quote "To be, or not to be:that is the question" (Act III Sc I) is still one of the questions that it most pondered about. I also think it puts human existence into perspective and my interpretation of that quote is what is our role here on earth. What is our calling??? Now I know you can not answer a question with another question but if I had to rephrase Hamlet's question, that would be my attempt. It is really hard to answer Hamlet's question in life sometimes because we spend most of our life trying to seek that which we must be here on earth. I think some people spend their whole life trying to find out who they truly are or must become. They search for their main duty here on this planet. But in the end it is our choice to be or not to be............but what is the the right answer to that question?
hysteria
I love Psychology and I truly enjoyed reading Sigmund Freud's analysis on his patient Dora. I think it is very interesting to see how our dreams can be related to experiences we go through during our daily life. However, Dora's story was quite a sad story. It must not be easy however to come from a broken home and be forced to grow up before your was ready. It must also not be easy to live around all that chaos and having your mother suffer from mental issues and have your father be in an affair. It is a bit scary to know that this is how serial killers come about and its just really share to see what people have resorted to. There are truly people out there who need help and I find it interesting how they can be helped with an interpretation of their dreams.
Who you least expect....
Although the title of this novel was Great Expectations for other reasons but one that I found rather amusing was Joe and Pip's relationship. It is quite funny how Pip disliked Joe somewhat during a major part of the novel because of his simplicity and lack of resources. However, it was Joe who cared for Pip when he most needed it. I think sometimes we dislike people for their superficial appearance or who we interpret them to be but sometimes we are wrong. When we most need someone they are there to prove us wrong and show us that they do indeed have a heart and are willing to help us out probably even more then what relatives would. This is why I try to be friendly to everyone because as the bible says "Do unto others as you would like to be done unto you". This is a very wise advice that we should all try to live by because the person you least expect might be the one to help you out when you most need it.
Great Expectations
I am glad to see that Pip was able to experience both sides of life. He got to be rich and poor all in one lifetime and although there are many people who are able to experience the same thing within a lifetime it is usually people who were once rice and are now poor. You barely ever see a poor person get rich and then get poor again. One of our greatest examples of this is Oprah Winfrey. She came from extreme poverty to extreme richness. Although, Pip lost part of who he was when he made the shift I like the fact that he still maintained part of who he was in the end. I am also glad that he was able to acknowledge Magwitch for his hard work and care to gave Pip all that he had. It is funny how money can change someone but in the end I think Pip learned a valuable lesson and as an artist once put it, "the more money you have, the more problems you have".
Learning.
One of the parts in Frederick Douglass' autobiography was when he vowed to himself to learn how to read regardless of his master's reluctance to have his wife teach him. It was very inspiring to me because sometimes their are people who defy our ability to gain a high degree of knowledge and they doubt us but how sweet is proving them wrong. I feel like my whole experience in college has been a giant laugh in the face of those who thought I would not make it. I feel its important to be your own cheerleader when no one else will be. Sometimes you need to keep yourself going and pick your oneself up when you are feeling alone or like you can't finish something. At the end of the day you only have yourself and you truly are indeed trying to succeed for yourself. I think it was a victory for mankind when Douglass taught himself to read and write because even now we find that there are people within the United States who have the opportunity and resources to get good educations and they don't. It truly was an awesome thing to read that he not only taught himself but that he learned to do so in a very eloquent manner. I thank Frederick Douglass for taking all his might and learning how to do so because someone else in his situation would have let it go and not tried to prove those people wrong. He is truly an inspiration.
Happy Birthday
Frederick Douglass' autobiography truly did inspire me. I think so many people get carried away complaining about the issues in their life that are sometimes smaller than other that they fail to see their potential to be happy. I consider being able to celebrate your birthday a true victory. It signals one more year you have on earth with loved ones and of having life. There are so many things that can happen to you in the blink of an eye and yet here you are celebrating one more year. It is a very cruel thing not to know the exact date in which you came into this world. Its a cruel thing not to know the exact number of years that you have lived on this earth. I believe that part of what identifies you as a person is your age. People are so obsessed with celebrating anniversaries and birthdays that its hard to imagine someone who is not able to share in the same joy. I believe that we do indeed take those small things for granted. They are major milestones in our lives however because they signal a defining triumph in our lives. It is an amazing feeling when you accomplish something great at a young age because then people look up to you or if you have been in something for long years like a marriage. People also mourn or hold dates in which loved ones have passed close to their hearts and remember them on those particular dates. Therefore, knowing when you were born is just as important as the day you pass away. It is a real shame to live and not be able to tell your exact birth day. I just celebrated my 21st birthday Dec 1st and I had been planning for it since my 18th birthday and to have not known my birthday would've been torture. My birthday is a very important day to me as everyone's should be to them.
The secret to true Love........
The second pair of quotes that touched me from Emerson were; If you can love me for what I am, we shall be the happier", "Nothing can bring you peace but yourself". Although these two quotes don't seem to go hand in hand it reminded me of how a true relationship should be. I don't think people realize that besides looking for what you want in a relationship you should also look for what you need. I think its important to be able to be satisfied on your own within having someone else to make you feel good. There are many people who go on the notion that another person is supposed to make them feel complete but I beg to differ. I think we should already be a whole person before we get into a relationship because like Emerson says, your ultimately the only person who can bring peace to your life. And if you are truly a whole person, satisfied with who you are and love yourself then someone else should be able to love you easily.
Saturday, December 20, 2008
Past, Present and Future
As I mentioned before, Emerson's Self-Reliance has truly impacted my life. If I could I would write all my blogs on him but there were two quotes that really stuck out to me. The first one I wish to write about first is the one that says, "Speak what you think now in hard words, and to-morrow speak what to-morrow thinks in hard words again, though it contradict every thing you said to-morrow". This is very touching and amazing because sometimes we hold back from saying or doing things because we feel like we will be judged because of our past actions. I know this holds truth for parents. How can you punish your child for something you would practice in the past when you were their age? Is this not a contradiction? But Emerson helps us understand that who we are today evolves from who we were yesterday and what we have become is a result of our past foundation. I find myself holding back on things I want to say or do because I feel like people will look at me wrong. If I stand for something in the past then I should still stand for it now right? Wrong! We are people and we change our views as often as we change our shoes for new ones. I think it is important to keep an open mind and challenge our views with present ones. I do not believe in things being set in stone. I wrote a blog previously about Mrs. Dalloway and things we view as mistakes. I do not think we should view things so negatively, even if they are a mistake we have the power to change it into something positive. We must learn to be satisfied with our lives no matter what and learn from those mistakes. They are what help us from falling back in the same spot we did in the first place. And thanks to Emerson, I have learned something knew; Speak what you think today and do not worry about the past because the past is just that.
Inspiration
One of the works that we read during the semester that truly changed my perspective on life was Ralph Waldo Emerson. I had read his essay self-reliance back when I was in high school but I just looked at it as being long and boring. This time when I read it I couldn't put the paper down. I believe it touches upon a lot of truths that my generation are not aware of. I find it intriguing how past works written long ago can still apply to the present. I guess trends do repeat themselves. I think it is important for us to read literature and see what the great minds wrote about because chances are that we can learn something to better our present living. I was extremely happy to revisit this work because I would have never done so on my own. I learned a lot more and appreciate it much more than when I was in high school. I loved it so much that most of the essay is highlighted. But it did speak to my life and I have already begun to apply it to my daily living. It is a timeless piece of art.
Greed is the root of all Evil
In Chaucer's Canterbury Tales, one of the the characters was the Pardoner and his story was about three men who were looking for death to kill it or him because it had taken their friend. They come across the old man who tells them that death is under a tree and once they arrive there they find gold coins. These men had been drinking and the sight of these gold coins just sparks more thirst to keep drinking. The Pardoner mentioned radix malorum est cupiditas or greed is the root of all evil and we see this illustrated as the men end up killing one another and in fact finding death itself. This is very interesting because many times we question how people can be so cruel. And this one way to see how people can be so malicious. My question is; how can people let themselves be driven or consumed by greed? I believe that in some instance in our lives we come across a person or experience something that truly breaks our hearts and bares it down to its purest form. We are all humans who once in a while will need help and a lending hand. Christmas is coming up and I remember reading the story of The Christmas Carol where Ebenezer Scrooge is the main character and he is a cold hearted old man. He has lots of money and doesn't give any to charity or to help a person in need. It takes a life experience with visitations from three Christmas spirits and a preview of his death to make him change. Now I come to my point why is it that the death of a person is what changes them? The three men at the tree could not change because death itself took their chance but for others its what they need in order to change. Why can't people just change because they yearn to do good from the beginning? Why does it take death to change a bad person? Doesn't good exist in all of us naturally?
Spice of Life
I was very intrigued by a comment that was made about Mrs. Dalloway. She questioned if her decision to marry Richard instead of Peter was indeed the correct choice. Then we spoke about in class how choices that we make can not be undone and that sometimes they are viewed as mistakes. Sometimes we are forced to live with these choices for the rest of our lives. But how is it that our past choices come to be viewed as mistakes? I believe it is our human desire of being in control. We are constantly trying to be on top of things and some people even map their day minute by minute. When we start to feel like things are a mistake its because we realize we only have so much power in our hands. We can not turn back time, press pause or fast forward on our life to seek a preview of whats to come. We do not have super abilities to time travel. This idea reminded me of the movie Click. The guy in the movie has a remote control that allows him to fast forward, pause, stop and rewind his life. But no matter how many times he uses the remote and changes something in the past, the present and future become drastically altered. In the show Heroes, the character Hiro is able to time travel and yet he understands that any change he brings upon any situation can cause major changes in the future. Even if its killing a fly! And so with this in mind, life is mysterious and while others say variety is the spice of life; I say the mystery itself is the spice of life.
Wednesday, December 17, 2008
Its funny I dreaded having to do a presention but I really enjoyed the last two classes. I brought us together as people not just as a class we just need to take. Everyone shined in how special we are and that was a trully beautiful thing that the professor was able to do. She brought us together on a personal level and it was comfortable too.
Friday, December 12, 2008
last two classes
i found that the last two classes was a touching moment on how people felt about other people. the girl that end up crying while reading her essay touched me the most on how she was talking about god. i find it very hard to forgive god for taking my mother away from me when she was the most caring person in the world. i felt like it was not her time yet. but i found that my mother death made me become a stronger n caring person. i learn he take the good ones for a reason.
Wednesday, December 10, 2008
Presentations on December 11
Presentations we had today were fantastic!!! I think you guys did an excellent job, and as professor Nadell said everybody interpreted the final project's question differently.
I believe we all learned new stuff today, about great people who inspired each one of you. And do not worry about anxiety that some of us had (including me) in public speaking, it will come to you with an experience. Trust me.
Now study hard hard for the final. I'll see you all at the final!
I believe we all learned new stuff today, about great people who inspired each one of you. And do not worry about anxiety that some of us had (including me) in public speaking, it will come to you with an experience. Trust me.
Now study hard hard for the final. I'll see you all at the final!
The End....
We'd have come to end of class and I am more than thankful for having been part of such a dynamic group. I learned so much more than I expected, not only from the works we'd read, but also from all of you through your participation in class. For those who presented already, good job and thanks for sharing such powerful stories. I am excited about hearing the rest of the presentations today. Happy Holidays, everyone!
Mrs. Dalloway's Artifical Life
Woolf strived to illustrate the vain and artificial life of Clarissa and her involvement in it. The detail given and thought provoked in one day of a woman's preparation for a party or a simple social event exposes the superficial lifestyle of England's upper classes at the time of the novel. Even though Clarissa is affected by Septimus' death and is bombarded by profound thoughts throughout the novel, she is also a woman for whom a party is her greatest offering to society. Women like Clarissa found self-worth in offering to host or entertain guests.
Tuesday, December 9, 2008
Who stood out to me today?
I really liked the girl who was talking about her mother today. It made me think of my mother and her actions throughout her life and how even the little things can be important. I also really liked Sophia's person, Eli (I don;t remember his last name). As a Jew, I found the story she talked about fascinating and very touching. Its amazing to have such an experience and not have anger in you...
Monday, December 8, 2008
Mrs. dalloway
It seem that regret is something that happens to everyone. we wish that we had done something us in the past when life doesnt end the way you wish it be, by the time you reach as age such as 40 years old. some time it had to change your life back around so you end up just living that boring life of your. Clarissa may have not been happy in her marriage so when she thought of Peter exboyfriend she thinks how would her life be if she had married Peter. For me my mother past away 3 years ago and i will always wonder how my life would have been if my mother was still alive.
The depth of Virginia Woolf
Although I found the book hard to follow I really appreciated the new insights and clarity we gained in class. Virginia Woolf's techniques are so nicely executed. Her stream of consciousness and free association really cause the reader to add depth to their lives. We are forced to think of others, as we walk down the street; we start to think about how we effect others lives. Our actions create ripple effects. I applaud Woolf for her techniques and her ability to draw our humanistic characteristics to the surface.
Friday, December 5, 2008
Frederick Douglas
I think Frederick Douglas is such an inspiring man. I do not know where he got the strength to pull through and not be beaten. He is just such a powerful figure. I think the the dehumanization that went on with slavery was sick. I do not understand how people could do these awful things to each other and sleep at night. It is quite disturbing the world we live in...how so much hate exists.
Wasteland
What is amazing about this poem is the one thing that makes it so hard to understand. The way it jumps to different speakers and memories captures the true loss of the war. Peoples' dreams and memories of the way things were were lost. The world was desolate and the war could not be forgotten and neither could its damage.
Mrs. Dalloway
Although the writing style was a little confusing I think it was a really great insight into the human mind. How we constantly are cycling our thoughts and how in the most random of moments we can remember obscure memories that we thought we had forgotten.
"The Best Portion of a Good Man's Life"
Further thoughts on the theme of
"that best portion of a good man's life,
His little, nameless, unremembered, acts
Of kindness and of love." (Tintern Abbey)
These are the final lines of George Eliot's Middlemarch. She writes of the heroine, Dorothea Brooke:
"Her full nature, like that river of which Cyrus broke the strength, spent itself in channels which had no great name on earth. But the effect of her being around those around her was incalculably diffusive: for the growing good of the world is partly dependent on unhistoric acts; and that things are not so ill with you and me as they might have been, is half owing to the number who lived faithfully a hidden life, and rest in unvisited tombs."
"Fear No More"
Fear no more the heat o` the sun,
Nor the furious winter`s rages;
Thou thy worldly task hast done,
Home art gone, and ta`en thy wages.
Golden lads and girls all must,
As chimney-sweepers, come to dust.
Fear no more the frown o` the great;
Thou art past the tyrants stroke;
Care no more to clothe and eat;
To thee the reed is as the oak.
The sceptre, learning, physic, must
All follow this, and come to dust.
Fear no more the lightning flash,
Nor th` all-dreaded thunder stone;
Fear not slander, censure rash;
Thou hast finished joy and moan.
All lovers young, all lovers must
Consign to thee, and come to dust.
No exorciser harm thee!
Nor no witchcraft charm thee!
Ghost unlaid forbear thee!
Nothing ill come near thee!
Quiet consummation have;
And renowned be thy grave!
From Cymbeline, Shakespeare
Nor the furious winter`s rages;
Thou thy worldly task hast done,
Home art gone, and ta`en thy wages.
Golden lads and girls all must,
As chimney-sweepers, come to dust.
Fear no more the frown o` the great;
Thou art past the tyrants stroke;
Care no more to clothe and eat;
To thee the reed is as the oak.
The sceptre, learning, physic, must
All follow this, and come to dust.
Fear no more the lightning flash,
Nor th` all-dreaded thunder stone;
Fear not slander, censure rash;
Thou hast finished joy and moan.
All lovers young, all lovers must
Consign to thee, and come to dust.
No exorciser harm thee!
Nor no witchcraft charm thee!
Ghost unlaid forbear thee!
Nothing ill come near thee!
Quiet consummation have;
And renowned be thy grave!
From Cymbeline, Shakespeare
Wednesday, December 3, 2008
Mrs. Dalloway
I really enjoyed this novel even though the changes of the characters was a bit confusing at times. Woolf's idea of having the different points of view from each character was great. Regret is something that can take over a person's life. Everyone has done something in their life they regret. This novel teaches us that we are meant to make certain choices or a specific path in life for a reason. There had to be something that allowed Clarissa to make her choice and marry Richard instead of Peter. Now she just has to deal with the "consequences" of her choices.
Surprised
I'm surprised that once this book was discussed in class, how much Mrs. Dalloway/Clarissa's character appeals to me. To me, she represents all of us in the world who don't make that huge splash in history. She shows us that there is more behind the title. Like the professor said, you can think "housewife" but behind that, there are choices, experiences and emotions, and each one of them having an impact on someone else out there, even if it's just one person.
The fact that she stews over past choices is very... real to me. Its something I feel many of us would or will do in the future, especially after we begin making tough choices in our lives. I'll def go back and reread this book when I'm older... I'll probably have an even BIGGER appreciation for it!
The fact that she stews over past choices is very... real to me. Its something I feel many of us would or will do in the future, especially after we begin making tough choices in our lives. I'll def go back and reread this book when I'm older... I'll probably have an even BIGGER appreciation for it!
Mrs. Dalloway
After discussing Mrs. Dalloway in class I have come to realize that the choices and decisions that we make are finite. They cant be changed once they are made and often there are times when we wished that we had picked the other option. Clarissa to me is one of these people. She thinks about what her life might have been had she married Peter and not Richard. Just the fact that she is thinking about it shows us that maybe she does think that she made the wrong decision. Her life isnt fulfilling, all she does is plan parties and never worked. To some this isnt a satisfying life but to her it is life and what keeps her busy.
mrs dalloway
i got really confused in the beginning when reading this book. the writing is abrupt and detailed and sometimes makes you forget the bigger picture. It's like zooming in a lens so much that you can't tell what the picture is a part of anymore. But after reading a bit, it becomes easier to understand her writing. Her writing, i think, it true to what really goes on in one's head. Our thoughts are not sensible, they jump around from one topic to another depending on the stimulus we receive.
Mrs. Dalloway
Clarissa is the typical woman who reflects back on the decisions she has made in her life and goes over in her head whether she made the right choice or not. Although she loves her husband, its evident that she wishes she had married Peter. She knows her life with Peter wouldn't have been easy but she regrets sacrificing love and passion for security and upper-class luxury. I feel many women in this world can sympathize with Clarissa's situation because as women we constantly wonder whether passion overcomes logic and sensibility.
Waste land
Eliot's Waste Land was a very confusing poem. Without knowing about the many voices he uses it seems like he is just crazy. But i do understand what he trying to accomplish with this post war poem. After understanding the many ideas he trying to convey you can see how he expresses the ideas of confusion, hopelessness and chaos, especially with the use and repetition of the phrase "unreal city".
Monday, December 1, 2008
Mrs. Dalloway
I found this book a little bit difficult to read at first because of the changing of voices and scenes. It seemed very abrupt and it was hard to understand. However I find it interesting to read about how a woman looks back onto her life and thinks of how she would change things or how things could have been different. Many people go through this and it's always fascinating to see how people change their thoughts of the past, even if it's in a fictional work. I'm looking forward to seeing how things turn out and how the book concludes, despite the difficulty that comes from reading it.
mrs. dalloway
i cant believe the only female author is the one were reading at the end! but its interesting toget a woman;s voice out there! mrs dalloway is interesting because it talks about past loves and REGRET! this is a feeling most people feel every day in one way or another, unfortunately it eats at people and sometimes ruins their chances for more, in the case of mrs dalloway, she chose the safer road and not with peter, i am glad to continue reading to see where it takes her
Sunday, November 30, 2008
Wasteland
I found this poem to be very hard to understand. The fact that it keeps switching from speaker to speaker is so confusing. It also switched a lot from place to place and time to time. You can tell that the poem is going to be kind of dark from the beginning lines..." April is the cruellest month..."
Wednesday, November 26, 2008
TS Eliot... not so fun
The product of a post world war era, this poem speaks volumes about the state of mind and the barrenness/hopelessness/emptiness of that period in time. The content of the poem hits home, and tells the points of view and many different types of post WWI stories. His countless references to other poets, poems, and artists is genius.
The content is fine... how the poem is written, however, I have a problem with. The "voice" of the story constantly changes, sometimes within the same section. It's choppy and very confusing, and changes location, time and speaker too often for me to truly "enjoy" (if its possible to enjoy such a sad poem) the content of this poem.
The content is fine... how the poem is written, however, I have a problem with. The "voice" of the story constantly changes, sometimes within the same section. It's choppy and very confusing, and changes location, time and speaker too often for me to truly "enjoy" (if its possible to enjoy such a sad poem) the content of this poem.
T.S. Elliot & the Waste Land.
It is truly fascinating how we are reading books that are connected with our society today. I actually think that we are living in a waste land. Even though we are surrounded with so much materialism, not only the goods that we use go to waste, but also our human values are going to the waste as well. Personally, the War in Iraq is the most horrible and yet ridicoulous war in history. And am I worried about my cousin's life after he comes back. Is he going to continue being funny and positive all of the time, like he used to be before he was sent to Iraq? After reading Elliot's poem, I thought about the soldiers coming back from Iraq and how society would deal with them. It's scary what is going to happen after the war is over. But all I know is that life should be valued at all costs, more than competition for power and wealth and unfortunately it is not. Is that how 'modern' we have come?
T.S Eliot
I have to say that i really didn't understand the poem as i was reading it. I notice that he used a lot of repetition in his poem and also had conversations as well. he used a lot of rhymes throughout his poem. i was a lot difficult to understand because the would jump from one speaker to another speaker.
Tuesday, November 25, 2008
Federic Douglas
When I started BC, I saw a documentary about Frederic Douglas and his accomplishments. And now reading the book, it is completely fascinating how he created himself to be well educated from not knowing how to write his name and not knowing his birthday to a person that became a famous abolitionist and now a known figure through out the world. His figure will be important in history that we can actually see his action to a positive outcome in the today's world. I find him inspiring and someone that never gave up to reach his goal.
Monday, November 24, 2008
T.S. Elliot
The lack of structure and switching of the speakers in The Wasteland was confusing and a bit hard to understand. When we took it apart in class today I had a better understanding of what Elliot was trying to say. The abrupt juxtapositions were interesting with the way Elliot discusses the lack and excess of water as well as the three common recurring themes -water, rocks/stones and an unreal city. It was interesting to read about the different quotes and references made to other authors in other works as well.
wasteland
I found Elliot's poem to be very confusing. I didn't particularly like it and to be honest I really didn't understand it. After discussing it in class my confusion was somewhat removed but I still didnt get a lot of it. I felt that it was very random and had many different thoughts coming out of nowhere. I didnt like how Elliot would speak and then there would be a voice. I really dont have much to say about this poem.
t s elliot
these kinds of poems are unlike those that we are used to. instead of being repetetive and rhyming, they areless structured, switching to different speakers abruptly and without warning. ts elliot brings us this era after ww1 where nobody knows what to expect to what to do with this generation of nothing being known, or wxpected. this is why so many people of this generation came out wacked. his use of language when the couple is fighting is comfortable because of the realness to it and i enjoyed that!
Fredrick Douglas
Fredrick Douglas was really an amazing person!! He accomplished so much in his life. I think we can all learn about bravery and motivation from Fredrick. Even though he was a slave he rose up to be a great person. He became an abolitionist, women's suffragist and and author. He is one of the most prominent people in the history of America. He truly believed in the equality of all people. After two failed attempts he finally suceeds in escaping from his master. His book The Life of Frederick Douglas in an inspiration to everyone. It teaches us that no matter where you are in society you can rise up. His story is amazing and really helps portray his life as a slave.
Dora
I always found Frued's work very interesting. I've learned in many psychology classes about his defense mechanisms of repression and psychoanalysis. I remember learning that the unconscious sexual drive of infancy help shape personlaity. He is also famous for performing psychoanalysis though dialogue between the patient and the psychoanalyst. Im very happy we read Dora in class because I always wanted to understand how this method worked. I think its gross how Ida has feelings for her father.
Sunday, November 23, 2008
Oddly Enough...
(Or maybe Unfortunately enough!!) I saw the movie Great Expectations before I read it. I had encountered it before a few times throughout my academic career, but had never taken the time to actually sit and read it cover to cover leisurely. I cannot even say that I didnt rush through it this time but it was the frst time I read it fully though after watching the movie. I dont know why i brought that up!!...moving along!!.. I Identify with each of the characters in this story however the one I dentify with the most is Pip. Dickens seamlessly weaves together the innocence and flaws of character into a beautiful rendering of the human condition.
Freud's Dora...
On the whole, I have always found Freud VERY creepy. His constant inferences of sex and the subconcious mind, are ( to me) projected and hardly infered. I dont get why he is often dubbed as one of the greastest thinkers of our time. I mean I get it, but at the same time doesnt his clear perversion, take away from his genius. I have often heard many times Freud was not very helpful to his subject. Dora, is a clear case of that. It seems a little odd that the dreams that she does convey to Freud ( which are synomous to those of countless people even today) , he coud obscure into some incestuous sexual Fanstasy!! I actually don't get why we are reading this in this class!!!
(( BUT I ENJOY IT ANYWAY!!!))
Narrative of Frederick Douglas...
I have encountered this book before and every time I read it, I find it hard to digest. The account of this story is so chillingly cold and calm. However it is an amazing piece of literature and I forced myself to read it in its entirety. I remain impressed with Douglass' command over a language he was denied is captivating. The prose and and delivery of his thoughts to paper is unparralled, even by todays standards.
Techniques by T.S. Eliot
While reading T.S Eliot's "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock" I noticed a few interesting methods that Eliot used. He used a lot of repition. Repitition in actual sections and between sections. He seemed to be having conversations in the midst of his poem. He has a unique way of using rhymes. Every paragraph seems to have unique rythmic schemes. He seems to have an underlying meaning to the poem that is covered by his unique methods and style. I look foward to uncovering the real meaning behind the poems as we delve into them during class.
Friday, November 21, 2008
Dora
Freud's Dora was a weird book yet I loved it. I was kept on the edge of my seat till the end wondering how Freud would treat her. For someone so young to have to deal with these problems was troublesome and must have been heartbreaking. But then again this is Freud were talking about. He is known for his theories of how the unconscious mind works as well as the role of repression. I love psychology and I find it really interesting to see how Freud puts a spin of sexual desire in everything. The way he analyzes dreams and especially Dora's dreams is something powerful that has left an impression in psychology today.
Freud's Dora
I think it's interesting that so many people have a problem with Freud's constant connections to sex, because I felt that way too. I can't fully believe that everything in Dora's life is unconsciously connected to sex, rather than feelings of betrayal that her father is having an affair. Because I have trouble believing in Freud's "all neuroses are rooted in sex" premise, I have a little trouble believing his other statements as well. That he thinks Dora wanted to kiss him, for one, seemed farfetched and a bit egotistical, especially since Herr K smokes, so the fact that Freud smokes may be inconsequential.
I did not expect the ending - where Dora's Herr K./Frau K. situation is easily resolved and she comes back to Freud with a symptom relating to him. I also thought it a little...weird that Dora magically ends up fine - married to a guy who has liked her for some time, and accepting of her father's affair, albeit her normal disgust when it is mentioned.
I know that Freud had to leave certain details out of this case study - he explains his reasons why, including the fact that a discussion of his analytic methods would make this work too extensive - but I think that without those details I don't fully trust Freud's conclusions. How do we know that he didn't elicit details from Dora that may not have been true, or that he didn't ask her leading questions to fit his "sex issues" idea? Freud is constantly referring back to this other works, which makes it seem like this study is fueling his personal desires to validate his own work with this work. If that is the case, as I suspect, then he may be ignoring other explanations of Dora's symptoms so that he can instead highlight the explanation that best serves his own purpose.
I'm not sure why I am so mistrustful of Freud.
I did not expect the ending - where Dora's Herr K./Frau K. situation is easily resolved and she comes back to Freud with a symptom relating to him. I also thought it a little...weird that Dora magically ends up fine - married to a guy who has liked her for some time, and accepting of her father's affair, albeit her normal disgust when it is mentioned.
I know that Freud had to leave certain details out of this case study - he explains his reasons why, including the fact that a discussion of his analytic methods would make this work too extensive - but I think that without those details I don't fully trust Freud's conclusions. How do we know that he didn't elicit details from Dora that may not have been true, or that he didn't ask her leading questions to fit his "sex issues" idea? Freud is constantly referring back to this other works, which makes it seem like this study is fueling his personal desires to validate his own work with this work. If that is the case, as I suspect, then he may be ignoring other explanations of Dora's symptoms so that he can instead highlight the explanation that best serves his own purpose.
I'm not sure why I am so mistrustful of Freud.
Thursday, November 20, 2008
Dora
I think Freud is fascinating and I find that most of his thoughts about the mind are very plausible. However, it is the idea that he seems to always connect a person's problems with some sexual desire that just bothers me. Not only is it sexual but it is some sexual desire for one's parent. Like in Hamlet for example he says that Hamlet hates Claudius because he loves and wants his mother for himself. Not only do I find this idea disturbing, I find it absurd. I feel like Freud his own hidden agenda when finding the motives for a person's actions or psyche. By this I mean that the agenda always seems to find some way to connect the problem with a motive of his choice, i.e., some sexual fantasy regarding one's parent.
Wednesday, November 19, 2008
Freud's dreams
Dora is a story of a girl who suppressed several unpleasant events in her life that eventually began to manifest itself physically. Freud's search into Nora's dreams revealed to him her pyschological neuroses. The point, to me, of Freud's analyses is to show how Dora hid her most private feelings in her unconscious. Of course, Freud can't be Freud without linking 90% of her dreams to sexual feelings. I truly believe there is an unconscious, but the fact that a girl has "social or psychological problems" because she got stuck in the oral stage or she's jealous of her mother or has penis envy, etc, is a little harder and more far-fetched to believe.
Latent vs. Manifest
I think Freud has introduced important concepts to our vocabulary. I really enjoy how we analyzed Dora, understanding that we can agree or disagree if Freud has gone to far; but that there are common grounds of knowledge we can learn from him and other works and authors. One of Freud's concepts is latent vs. manifest. This suggests that one's unconscious (that which is latent) will eventually manifest itself in the conscious. I think learning these terms makes a person more aware of what they do and why they may do something. A certain characteristic we have now, we may be able to trace back to a childhood circumstance; not even in a far fetched way by more awareness of ourselves.
DORA
Dora is a complex character...at age fourteen normal girls are not going hysterical and i kind of feel like in a way she was forced to grow older too soon. she was in a confusing situation and thought that that was what her father wanted, so she continued it, even through her "disgust". all these thoughts were too much for her, too frustrating, so she started going a bit crazy, and then the physical symptoms started to follow due to her mind playing games on her. freud analyzes her, thinking that bringing her thouhgts forward can help her through these periods, i hope it works!
Freud
The mind is such a crazy and amazing thing. It works in mysterious ways that we have yet to figure out. Freud was interested in finding out why Dora resorted to acting the way that she did. Even though Freud believed in repression which can manifest itself in an action I myself am not totally convinced that we repress things that are to painful for our memories to handle. I think that if you dont want to think about something then you simply dont have but I dont think that things get pushed aside unconsciously. Dora was a strange and complex character and Freud's analysis showed us what he thought was the reason for her actions.
Douglass---A Great Human Being.
Despite the sad descriptions in his autobiography, Douglass gives to his readers a sense of hope and a good model of how human beings should live their lives. Throughout the book, there were a couple of scenes that I found disturbing, which led to close the book and picture an image on my mind of what he was describing. One scene that I would always remember is the one where he described how cracked his feet were because of the cold and how he could place his pen (the one he was writing with at the moment) in one of the holes. As painful as this description is, I found it to be so inspiring and hopeful because he is saying that he stepped above the exploitation he suffered as a slave. He is proving to the slave holders, especially his masters, that he is more than just someone who they can mistreat as much as they want and more than just someone who can work until his body can longer function. Douglass shows us that we too can be more than what other people and society as a whole may expect or think about us. We have the potential to be better human beings towards ourselves and others. We sometimes take for granted our inner power, that is, our abilities and talents. And I think that Douglass is saying that it should not be so, even when the situation around is difficult and may seem as if it is never going to end. I wonder what Douglass would say about our society today if he was alive. Even though slavery ended, are we moving forward or backwards?
Dora
Freud has a unique way in telling a story, or in his perspective a case. The concept of hysteria I believe is a anti-subplot, as Freud slowly discusses why Dora has hysteria; the main reason being that Mr.K kissed her and while he was kissing Dora he got aroused. Dora happened to feel Mr.K's penis. But i digress from a blog to book summary. Sorry. The concept of dreaming remains in part a study of interpretation to relate the unconscious and conscious self to reality. While all Dora's major influence happened to be male she acted as such. But all it takes is one moment of disgust to alter the psych completely.
Tuesday, November 18, 2008
Fredrick Douglas
After discussing the narrative in class I understand it much better. His explanations and descriptions of what it was like to be a slave are so vivid and clear making it easier to understand what life as a slave was really like. I was very interested in the passage where Douglas practically thanks his master for not allowing him to learn how to read and write. His teachings are immdeiately stopped but this doesnt necessarily stop Douglas from learning how to read and write. HE makes it his business to become a more educated person which I think is very admirable and at that time dangerous.
F. Douglass
I really enjoyed yesterday class, the professor really made me understand how Douglass really meant about slavery and slaveowners. He said that people who were slave's were less human when they really were human beings. Slaves were denied to be a human just because of the color of their skin. He explain to us how it was inhumane to be a slave.
Monday, November 17, 2008
Frederick Douglass
I've read this narrative before, but we never discussed the work in terms of how it was written. I've always found it, and still do, a very heartwrenching account of the effects of slavery. However, I love how Douglass is so eloquent and fights back against his slave owners with intelligence, cleverly twisting around arguments to show the indecency of the slave owners to slaves. He makes the slaveholders look ignorant, even moreso than they were. He holds himself at a higher level, not using profanity or unfair judgements on all people. He is feet, yards, miles, higher than any slave owner and he makes them look worse than dirt. They deserve this and I believe Douglass' work is very successful and I admire him greatly.
importance of slavery
todays class was very inspiring, showing us the particlar methods of Douglass' writings which he uses to show us different examples of slavery and the slaveowners. the fact that people who are slaves are defined as less human is based on the particular though that people are defined as human. to be a slave is to be denied this, the pursuit of your own interest, the pursuit of your own good, and is allowing that other people define this for you. Dougless has a powerful way of defining this to us, showing us how inhumane it was to be considered a slave!
Frederick Douglass
The narrative really opened up my eyes about Douglass and the criticisms he received in regards to whether or not he was truly a slave. It also somewhat puts into perspective of how some African-Americans are viewed today. I can understand the reasoning behind their assessments of Douglass. The fact that slaves around that time were not allowed to learn how to read and therefore could not write understandably brought up questions of how Douglass was able to not only read but write an entire book. Nevertheless, he still endured the hardships of slavery.
Today, there are some African-Americans that look at others of their same race as not understanding the true struggle of Black people today just because they have become professionals and are well respected and accepted by others from society. These African-Americans are looked at as having it "easier" than other African-Americans and therefore lack the support of others of their race.
Today, there are some African-Americans that look at others of their same race as not understanding the true struggle of Black people today just because they have become professionals and are well respected and accepted by others from society. These African-Americans are looked at as having it "easier" than other African-Americans and therefore lack the support of others of their race.
Sunday, November 16, 2008
Great Expectations
What do we expect life to be? A vast image as a child to ideally believe in the perception of any success. Only to feel anxiety as the hands of time turn forward and the optimistic view of life is that you frown upon. What happened to your dream? Work, responsibilities, and the lack of opportunities among us. Seeking miracles from outside sorces wether spirtiually or by a lottery ticket. The exceptional few who's life is altered by a sole purpose to change.
Douglass
Frederick Douglass, “If There Is No Struggle, There Is No Progress”. The most extreme form of abuse that in which is slavery where physically, mentally, and social implications are enforced and imposed. Douglass in a sense symbolizes the American dream; a constant battle till this day as the glass ceiling is raised, and social freedoms are taken away. Proposition 8, patriot act, Arizona removes affirmative action, one step forward and two steps back.
The Key to Freedom
Frederick Douglass did the invincible. He took the life he was given and accepted the challenge to improve. He used his owners “gift” to give hope and important testimony to the world. His gift of speech draws the reader. He speaks with subdued feeling yet expresses his points. The owners knew the key to their slave’s freedom: literacy and education. They therefore kept this from them. They took their slaves identities and treated them like animals. Douglass uses this power of freedom to turn his fellow friends and family into people and get the recognition they deserve.
New type of character study
This class, to me, is largely built on the characters we read and what it means to be human and to HAVE character. F. Douglass is different from any other thing we read so far because he writes about something more real and more sensitive than anything else so far. Reading about dehumanization of black people from that time and reading in detail the pains (literally AND figuritively) African Americans went through. Specifically, as a person of Jewish background, dehumanization of people really hits home to me, no matter if who is being dehumanized.
To not be considered human because of who you are or what you can't control, I think, is one of the greatest sins of humanity.
To not be considered human because of who you are or what you can't control, I think, is one of the greatest sins of humanity.
Saturday, November 15, 2008
Douglass
I haven't read a narrative like this about slavery before. The way Douglass portrayed the beatings and violence was extremely graphic. It never occurred to me the real hardships and cruelty that the slaves experienced. I never knew that the slaves were traded among the slave owners so often. It was interesting to see how Douglass learns to read and write. His determination to run away was so compelling yet exciting-for me at least.
Friday, November 14, 2008
Frederick Douglass
This narrative was so much more powerful than I had ever expected it to be. Having been alerted (by our class discussion) to the reasons behind Douglass' rational and collected narrative voice, I was able to bring my own emotional responses to his words to the forefront as I read. I was more affected by his story that way, and I also found it more scandalous. When he was plotting his first escape, and wrote the fake permission slips, I was gripping the book with fear and anticipation of what would happen. Oddly, his real escape story was much less...dramatic. I understand his reasons for not explaining the path he took to New York, but it felt weird that one moment he's in Maryland, and by the next sentence he has made it safely to New York...as though that was as easy as walking down the block.
I also noticed that Douglass addresses what we had mentioned in class about dehumanization - especially when he talks about how felt giving his hard-earned wages to Mr. Hugh.
I also noticed that Douglass addresses what we had mentioned in class about dehumanization - especially when he talks about how felt giving his hard-earned wages to Mr. Hugh.
Wednesday, November 12, 2008
Pip
I really loved the idea the Professor brought up in class about Pip the other day. I agree with the idea that his running away from his past was completely negated when the convict came back into his life. As soon as Pip leaves his home to be a “gentleman”, he is eager to shed them from himself. We see this when he doesn’t show appreciation Joe and fails to visit him and his sister on multiple occasions. However, with all the running away he has tried to do, everything comes back to him with the sudden return of his convict. His reappearance forces Pip to remember his family and real home, something that he has been trying to keep as far away as from his as possible. It makes you realize that you can't change where you come from but only embrace it and better yourself by it.
Frederick Douglass story
I like how he describes things, he doesnt seem to be angry or doesnt try to overexaggerate the sufferings, which he could have easily done. It's an interesting story, but I find it hard to relate to those people's lives , the things seem too unrealistic for me to comprehend in 2008. However, i'm sure the book had a lot more impact on people 100-150 years ago than it does now, and I think it has a lot of historic value too.
Frederick Douglass
F. Douglass was born in a time of slavery. I really felt sick in my stomach when Douglass was telling his story when he first witnessed as a child his Aunt Hester get whipped by her master. He said that the master would take great pleasure in whipping a slave. He would whip her harder the louder she screamed and where she would be bleeding. He would make her take off her clothes first before he would whip her. the only reason he had whipped her was because she didn't obey him when he told her not to go out on evening and never to be with a young man. I have to say that i don't know if i could have lived during this time of period.
Great Expectation
I really found Monday class to be interesting on the things that can get in our way in succeeding. For example Joe expectation for Pip was to become his helper as a blacksmith which did not happen. It must have been really hard for Pip to let Joe know that he didn't want to follow him in life. Some times your parents but to Pip his brother in law can get in your way in succeeding.
Great Expectations
At the end it seem that everybody had changed their character at the end. Nobody seem to be the same. Pip changed into a great person. The part i loved the most was we found out that Estella was the convict daughter when i read that part i really had my mouth open lol.
Great Expectations 2
I think our class discussion of how intentions don't succeed and how it related to the novel was very interesting. So much of our life actually is dictated by our parents expectations of us or other expectations of us. I think it confuses so many individuals and that is how we often lose out on knowing who we are because we can be shaped by others around us. Like Estella, I think it is unfair that not only was she taken away from her father all those years ago, she was raised to break hearts and in a sense never to love. How can it be okay for Ms. Havisham to take love away from someone? Love is one of life's most precious gifts.
Great Expectations
I think it is brilliant how Dickens completely flips the book by making Magwitch his benefactor instead of the awful memory Pip always viewed him as. I think Magwitch's tale is the most compelling of all and a terrible tragedy that leaves the longest lasting impression on me from the entire book.
Tuesday, November 11, 2008
The End of Great Expectations.
Yesterday's class discussion was very thought-provoking about the idea of 'success.' And what is 'success'? Is it the end product of a goal or intention that you set up to do? Or is it the steps that get you to achieve a certain that particular goal or intention? As discussed in class, sometimes external forces intervene in the way of accomplishing something that causes it to not come about as you may plan to. In Pip's case, I think his success of becoming a gentleman depended on the hard experiences that he went thorough as well as his realization of the mistakes he did in regards to not staying close to Joe and Magwitch. But even that is success because it is through mistakes that one is able to learn and move forward. We are not perfect, and gentlemen are no exception to the rule. Worthswood reminded us of that in the poem we read for class when he said that we have no control of the outcomes of our decisions as much as we plan it.
Sometimes we also have expectations for other people without understanding what it is that we are asking for. Although Magwitch fought so hard so that Pip could become a gentleman, maybe Pip wanted just a little bit of care and love from his father more than becoming a gentleman. Thus, in my opinion, it is important to consider people's life, skills, and desires before expecting something from them. In the end, it is the life of the individual that is going to be affected and they have the right to live their lives as they want. This is also the case with our own lives: Are we expecting something that 'we' want for ourselves? Or is it other people's expectations that we are living by? These are critical questions that Pip was questioning in his life as he was becoming a gentleman and that it is also important for us to reflect upon.
Sometimes we also have expectations for other people without understanding what it is that we are asking for. Although Magwitch fought so hard so that Pip could become a gentleman, maybe Pip wanted just a little bit of care and love from his father more than becoming a gentleman. Thus, in my opinion, it is important to consider people's life, skills, and desires before expecting something from them. In the end, it is the life of the individual that is going to be affected and they have the right to live their lives as they want. This is also the case with our own lives: Are we expecting something that 'we' want for ourselves? Or is it other people's expectations that we are living by? These are critical questions that Pip was questioning in his life as he was becoming a gentleman and that it is also important for us to reflect upon.
Estella's transformation
I think it is very interesting to focus on Estella's transformation throughout the whole book. She changes in many ways. She changes physically. She in not as pretty as she was in the beginning of the novel. She also changes emotionally. She definatly matures. She finally looks at Pip as her friend and doesnt look down on him anymore. She doesnt insult him or put him down. She relizes how snobby she was and how snobiness got her nowhere. She finally sees how much Pip loves her. We see how she matures because she asks Pip for forgiveness.
Monday, November 10, 2008
The End!
This novel had so many mysteries. When I first found out all the secrets about Magwitch, Estella, Compeyson and Miss Havisham, I was intrigued. It seems like Magwitch "took" Compeyson from Miss Havisham before Compeyson turned on him. In return, I guess Estella was brought to Miss Havisham and was taken away from Magwitch.
Although, Pip does not become a gentelman with the money, he does indeed become a gentelman through his behavior towards Magwitch. In the end of the novel, he treats him with respect and tries to help him escape. I think that in this way, Pip is returning the favor to Magwitch for being his benefactor.
Another important factor is that at the end of the novel, Joe is the one who comes to take care of Pip. He nurses Pip through his illness. Biddy teaches Joe how toread and write. It seems like he wants to be someone who Pip is not ashamed to call family, since Joe is all he's got. In the end, family is all you've got!
Although, Pip does not become a gentelman with the money, he does indeed become a gentelman through his behavior towards Magwitch. In the end of the novel, he treats him with respect and tries to help him escape. I think that in this way, Pip is returning the favor to Magwitch for being his benefactor.
Another important factor is that at the end of the novel, Joe is the one who comes to take care of Pip. He nurses Pip through his illness. Biddy teaches Joe how toread and write. It seems like he wants to be someone who Pip is not ashamed to call family, since Joe is all he's got. In the end, family is all you've got!
pip and magwitch
in great expectations, we see characters trying to repair their past by taking in younger people to do this for them. we see magwich give pip a lifethat he could never have and we see mrs. havisham try to break men's hearts as a form of revenge over the man who left her. these reparations dont go according to plan, since magwichs story ends with leaving pip not as a gentleman, but as an average man, but with more knowledge and mrs havisham has second thoughts after seeing how estella broke pips hearts!
Sunday, November 9, 2008
Estella
I know that, despite her cold heart, we are made to sympathize with Estella, because she is taught by Miss Havisham to break hearts and to be cold. Despite this logic, I really don't like her at all. I can't feel sorry for her because she is just so cold throughout. And I know that it was because of her upbringing and all of that, but I have known many people as well, who have been brought up in a similar way and do not act as Estella does. I think I really need someone to explain to me and just to sell me on being sympathetic towards her character, because I just don't feel it. She tells Pip that she would hurt him, and warns him continually, but I just don't see how her upbringing can be used as a cop out to be rude to everyone and look down on them. Can anyone sell me on sympathy for her?
Philip Pirrip
I want to say a couple of words about Pip. Well first of all, Pip's character is typical orphan character. Another thing is that he is in some way stubborn and career-like person. His stubborness can be seen for example how he devotes a lot of time pursuing Estella.I can say that Pirrip had done a great job of changing. I think his spirit and his desire to get better, because he is ashamed of himself through the novel is fantastic. Not many people have such a big willpower.
I also wonder how Philip looks like, because we never got physical description of him. Anybody can describe me him physically? I wonder how you guys imagined Pip while you were reading this novel...
I also wonder how Philip looks like, because we never got physical description of him. Anybody can describe me him physically? I wonder how you guys imagined Pip while you were reading this novel...
Great Expectations
After reading Great Expectations I think that it is important in life to follow your dreams no matter how impossible they may seem. Pip had a dream of becoming a gentleman and even though it was handed to him and required no effort on his part he still achieved it. Dreaming allows people to think about what might be and allows them to become more than they already are. I think that when someone does reach their goal it is important not to forget about the ones who helped you reach that goal as Pip did. He forgot about the people that loved him and looked down on them as if they werent good enough and I think that this was his biggest mistake and regret. In life I think it is healthy to want more for yourself or how else would anyone ever accomplish anything.
Great Expectations - The End
The two endings did not seem as different as I had expected them to. In fact, many phrases are repeated. The only thing that differed was the tone, I think, because the original ending seems less optimistic. We aren’t told that Estella has come to terms with Miss Havisham’s teachings, only that she doesn’t seem to be under them any longer.
As for how things turned out – well, who really survives? It doesn’t seem like anybody does, except perhaps Herbert. To go through the list of characters:
Mrs. Joe, Miss Havisham, and Magwitch are obviously dead.
Joe is alive and still honorable, but his relationship to Pip isn’t exactly what it once was, as seen by his hesitation and use of ‘sir’ when Pip gets stronger and recovers from his illness. Can he really be seen as the same exact Joe?
Estella is…changed, though we don’t really know enough about her to know the extent of the change. She certainly is less proud, no matter which ending you choose to go by.
Pip has suffered the death of Magwitch and the loss of Estella. He has definitely changed.
It is interesting to note, (considering the way we had dissected the title in class) that the only expectation you can ever be sure of is death, and indeed, that seems to be what looms over this novel from the beginning (when we meet Pip at his parent’s graves) to the end.
As for how things turned out – well, who really survives? It doesn’t seem like anybody does, except perhaps Herbert. To go through the list of characters:
Mrs. Joe, Miss Havisham, and Magwitch are obviously dead.
Joe is alive and still honorable, but his relationship to Pip isn’t exactly what it once was, as seen by his hesitation and use of ‘sir’ when Pip gets stronger and recovers from his illness. Can he really be seen as the same exact Joe?
Estella is…changed, though we don’t really know enough about her to know the extent of the change. She certainly is less proud, no matter which ending you choose to go by.
Pip has suffered the death of Magwitch and the loss of Estella. He has definitely changed.
It is interesting to note, (considering the way we had dissected the title in class) that the only expectation you can ever be sure of is death, and indeed, that seems to be what looms over this novel from the beginning (when we meet Pip at his parent’s graves) to the end.
Saturday, November 8, 2008
Almost Done with Great Expectations!
This reads like a soap opera! I am not quite finished with Great Expectations, but the chapters detailing the discovery of Estella’s lineage (first her mother, then her father) and Miss Havisham repenting for the way she raised Estella was so drama-filled that I could have been watching Days of Our Lives rather than reading a classic novel!
I thought it was interesting that after so many chapters of seeing Estella as a reflection of Miss Havisham, it turns out that Pip is more like Miss Havisham. I also think it is interesting that Miss H. chooses to purge her sins through fire, especially since Pip clearly avoids fire (the forge fire, and also the flame of Orlick’s candle).
It’s so crazy that this charged novel is able to come to so neat a close. Estella’s parentage is not going to be revealed to her, and in fact Miss Havisham didn’t know the majority of the details. Miss Havisham has lost Estella, as has Pip, and it seems that Drummle will never really have her. The mysterious maid of Jaggers’ that Wemmick said to watch for has turned out to be Estella’s mother and Magwitch (!) her father, though neither parent knows of their daughter’s fate and they wouldn’t recognize her if they had seen her. The irony here is, of course, that Magwitch loves Pip because Pip reminds him of Estella, and surely Magwitch, if he had the power, would give Estella to Pip in marriage. As it happens, everyone seems left at a loss, and finally Pip sees that it is better to live simply and well than to live life in the fast lane.
Although, I’m not quite done, so there may yet be surprises…
I thought it was interesting that after so many chapters of seeing Estella as a reflection of Miss Havisham, it turns out that Pip is more like Miss Havisham. I also think it is interesting that Miss H. chooses to purge her sins through fire, especially since Pip clearly avoids fire (the forge fire, and also the flame of Orlick’s candle).
It’s so crazy that this charged novel is able to come to so neat a close. Estella’s parentage is not going to be revealed to her, and in fact Miss Havisham didn’t know the majority of the details. Miss Havisham has lost Estella, as has Pip, and it seems that Drummle will never really have her. The mysterious maid of Jaggers’ that Wemmick said to watch for has turned out to be Estella’s mother and Magwitch (!) her father, though neither parent knows of their daughter’s fate and they wouldn’t recognize her if they had seen her. The irony here is, of course, that Magwitch loves Pip because Pip reminds him of Estella, and surely Magwitch, if he had the power, would give Estella to Pip in marriage. As it happens, everyone seems left at a loss, and finally Pip sees that it is better to live simply and well than to live life in the fast lane.
Although, I’m not quite done, so there may yet be surprises…
Thursday, November 6, 2008
Pip - Great Expectations
I cant help but feel bad for Pip. He had such a hard life ,growing up without parents. His grew up in an abused house with his sister who treats him bad. All he wants to do is be good enough for Estelle. He is ashamed of his family and of himself. He wants to better himself. Pip's character is not a rare one to find one. Many people in society feel the need to always try to impress and impress and impress. They are ashamed of who they are and where they came from. They try to hide their past and pretend they are someone else. People like Pip have to understand that everything does happen for a reason and that the sitaution that they are in is all supposed to happen and part of a greater plan. Every person is put into a life that is meant for them. They must learn how to accept that life and learn how to deal with it. Rich or poor they must accept their past and use it for the future. I feel bad for Pip because he is such a young boy and doesnt know how to accept his life. Instead he tries to hide from it and is ashamed of it.
I found today's class really interesting. Its strange how things in the book turn out. I never would have associated Magwitch with being Pip's "father". But now as I look back at how Pip had all these repressed memories of his childhood buried inside, Magwitch was really like his father. It is really ironic how they met at his parent's graves. Magwitch is the reason Pip was able to be a "gentleman".
Why wouldnt you thank someone for giving you everything you've ever dreamed of?
And Pip, if you were already at home, why wouldnt you go visit your family?
Why wouldnt you thank someone for giving you everything you've ever dreamed of?
And Pip, if you were already at home, why wouldnt you go visit your family?
Wednesday, November 5, 2008
Estella
Having read this story before (though honestly not really liking it) I have always found interest in Estella's character. Raised by Miss Havisham, Estella grows up learning to be manipulative, cold-hearted, and stoic.
If not for Miss Havisham, I think her and Pip wouldve had an excellent life together. Dicken uses Estella as a message to the readers, trying to say that class doesnt necessarily equal happiness. To me, Estelle is the perfect example of that. She grows up with Miss Havisham, but ends up being unhappy and marries a cruel man. If she lived with someone like Joe instead, poor but honest and kind, she would have been a much more fulfilled and happy woman.
In the end, I like Estelle because she comes off throughout the book as someone who questions the way she has been brought up, always questioning who she really is inside without all the scorned knowledge of living with Miss Havisham. To question oneself, I think, is to be human, and to have humanity.
If not for Miss Havisham, I think her and Pip wouldve had an excellent life together. Dicken uses Estella as a message to the readers, trying to say that class doesnt necessarily equal happiness. To me, Estelle is the perfect example of that. She grows up with Miss Havisham, but ends up being unhappy and marries a cruel man. If she lived with someone like Joe instead, poor but honest and kind, she would have been a much more fulfilled and happy woman.
In the end, I like Estelle because she comes off throughout the book as someone who questions the way she has been brought up, always questioning who she really is inside without all the scorned knowledge of living with Miss Havisham. To question oneself, I think, is to be human, and to have humanity.
great expectations
If only Ip was never introduced to Miss Havisham and Estella. As soon as he was thrown into their world, he realized how different he was and hated it. It’s a terrible feeling to be put down so hard and looked upon as socially inept, but when you internalizes it and start hating yourself, it's a lot worse. Meeting Estella changed Pip’s view and perspective of the world and society. If he weren’t subject to her cruelty and coldness maybe, he would have lived a more peaceful life in the village. He would have learned to be a black smith and find love in Biddy who is one like himself. But now he can’t and he knows this especially when he confesses to Biddy herself, “If I could only get myself to fall in love with you”.
Estella: Who is she really?
This is my second time reading Great Expectations. I was always annoyed at Pip for being overcome by Estella. Reading it for a second time I wonder if Pip saw something in Estella that was genuine. Is Estella underneath all the coldness,an emotional being. At first glance she is a product of Miss Havisham. She is trained not to feel, not to love. But human nature does not allow a person to go about life without any emotions. Is she just playing a game with Pip or does she really come to love him? She orders Pip take her around, take her luggage. She is dictated by Miss Havisham? So is her snobbery really a front as the story progresses?
Pip & His Personal Transformation Struggle.
We had an interesting discussion in class today about Pip trying to forget about his past and focus on being a gentleman. I like the character Joe for his kind heart and caring personality. But I also think that Pip is not necessarily pushing him out of his life on purpose. Rather, Pip is trying to get away from his past. Let's face it: Pip had a horrible childhood and whether we may like it or not, Joe is part of that old life Pip wants to get rid of. I'm not saying Joe is bad, but sometimes we need to separate from things and people that remind us of painful experiences. It is not fair for Joe because he is not guilty of Pip's destiny as an orphan. However, Pip has all the right in the world to decide who his new family and network of friends are going to be. It is not an easy transformation Pip is going through--change itself is a struggle that requires sacrifice, it's a painful process, and it requires time and patience.
A True Gentleman
Joe represents the person who is happy with what he/she has. Situations come to him and he makes the best of them. He has a mean wife who then becomes an invalid. He raises Pip to have Pip turn his back on the simple blacksmith life for the life of a gentleman. But Joe remains calm and in control. His self esteem and confidence and pride in who he is can teach us important lesson. Joe never desired to be a formally trained gentleman. He is a self-made gentleman. He does not turn his back on Pip and adapts to the "London" situation very well. Joe is happy where he is in life while Pip is not. Dickens’s takes us on Pip's journey to compare the self-made gentleman with the society produced gentleman and see who comes out on top.
Pip's Flight Reaction
Pip’s reaction to Estella’s snobbery is admiration. A general reaction would be disgust. His unnatural reaction and obsession with Estella is just one example of his flighty attitude. Pip goes from one “expectation” to another. He does not know how to combine his family he left at home with his “becoming a gentleman.” His obsession with Estella and his passiveness toward Joe and Biddy (who imbued him with the only love and foundations that he ever had) stem perhaps from Pip being an orphan. He lost his family and his sister never wanted him. He lacks a sense of belonging and thinks by becoming a gentleman and marrying Estella he can create a completely new life.
repression
pip had a sense of repression towards his past that would not leave him alone. this was allthanks to that one night that he helped out that convict, and so he blamed himself for his involvement in criminality. he always tried to hide this and suppress it, but it came back one night to haunt him, when theconvict came back and opened that door that pip was trying so hard to keep shut. from here we learn a valuable lesson about life, we must end things because if not they will torture us!
Pips visit back home.
When Pip had went back to visit his child town he didn't go visit his sister or his brother inlaw Joe. I agree with him not going to see his sister but disagree with not going to visit Joe. Joe used to always have his back as a child when his sister would make him feel bad. I wish that he did go visit Joe beacause I think it would have met a lot to Joe.
I think even if Pip "makes it" in life, he will still feel isolated. Not only is he an orphan, but now he has to leave the only people he knows and adapt to a completely different environment, where i doubt he would ever be able to relate to anybody. Most likely he'll be miserable. But it's not just the story of Pip, i think many people have similar stories. You're born into your social status and it's really hard to change it. I dont know anybody who could become successful in life and not feel isolated from all their dear friends and family who live in poverty. But at least i think he is going to have more appreciation for his achievements.
Monday, November 3, 2008
"making it"
I think that Great Expectations is the epitome of a "making it" story. Pip comes from literally nothing and his life turns around and he becomes a gentleman in London. I think that he has a lot to learn about sticking by those who have been there for you, love you, and supported you. As soon as Pip reaches the status that he thinks is the best he forgets about his family and pays no attention to the people that care about him. It is important to remember those that have helped you along the way even if they dont end up the same way as you do. He comes to regret how he treated Joe and I think that this is noble of him to admit it.
great expectations
todays discussion in class really pinpointed what we love about fairy tales and people who have to struggle to make it in life. pip had nothing growing up and was subjected to his sister's violent behavior and we would have thought that thats what he was going to be doing for the rest of his life. he had a "life sentence" to being a blacksmith until this unknown benefactor changed his life. by giving him money, he also gave him a new personality, one who was embarassed of his roots and of the people he associates with. this is true of many people who strike gold and dont k now how to handle it, but despite this, im still rooting for Joe to realize that what is most imporatnt are his roots, because without the past there wouldnt be a future!
Greater Expectations of Myself!
I love great expectations and wish that I had mroe time to get into it at a leisurely pace!!.. I love pip and find his character endearinga nd sad ... although Pip is forced to grow up wuickly and deal wuith things that he should have to ...he has not lost any innocence because he is pure of heart. I think he represents a part of all of us... and the characters around him all share sides of what I feel are the flaws of adulthood. There is some perfection in the ignorrance of youth, and a horrible trade is made in order to "grow up " and mature. Like I said I wish I had more of an opportunity to enjoy the book!
Sunday, November 2, 2008
great expectations
I love Pip's character. I genuinely feel bad for him and the situaiton that he's in. No child should have to live through the torture and abuse as he does. He is so neglected and has no connection with his sister that he ends up identifying with the convict instead of finding help in his family. The convict, like Pip, has no one to really turn to, no family, no identity, and has been kicked out society. Pip helps him out instead and shows that he is sympathetic despite harshness he has been subjected to.
Saturday, November 1, 2008
great expectations
I didnt read the whole book yet, only about 1/3 so far. Pip is an orphan and he lives with his older sister and her husband, Joe. Joe seems to be about the only person Pip likes. Sometimes it looks like Pip doesn't like people all that much in general. I know most of his relatives and other characters do not seem to be good characters, but they are described from Pip's subjective point of view. He always refers to a person's appearance as one of the main factors he uses to judge them. Red face, looks like fish, etc.. Could be that it's only because he's still immature. He also finds it relatively easy to suppress his conscience about stealing or lying, Joe being an exception. But then , Estella treats him even worse than everybody else, but because she's good looking, he cannot develop any negative feelings towards her for that.
Thursday, October 30, 2008
expectations
I never really paid attention to why so many novels were written about orphans. But then again, they were usually the most interesting for me. When I read the opening paragraph, before we discussed it in class, I didn't think that Pip created his own identity. I, being a speech major, thought he wasn't able to pronounce Phillip and therefore said Pip, which is easier. Young kids often create new words that parents use. I call my brother Jerry because I wasn't able to say Jeremy when I was younger. Now people call him Jerry. I didn't really create his identity.
Another thing, why did Pip go back and bring the convict the food and other stuff he asked for? Instead of helping the convict, why didn't he just forget about him altogether? It's not like he followed him home. It just seems odd and allows us to see that Pip is kind and has a generous heart.
Don't we all have certain expectations of people?
Another thing, why did Pip go back and bring the convict the food and other stuff he asked for? Instead of helping the convict, why didn't he just forget about him altogether? It's not like he followed him home. It just seems odd and allows us to see that Pip is kind and has a generous heart.
Don't we all have certain expectations of people?
Great Expectations 2
In the discussion about how the title great expectations is so great I realized that the title wasn't just about Pi. I eman can't we say that Ms. Havisham's great expectations was that she would get married and because he didn't show, she was shattered by it. Sometimes our own expectations can be set too high and can break us. People need to have secondary or backup expectations so that we do not get destroyed if our primary dreams or hopes aren't fulfilled.
Great Expectations
I think the class discussion about orphans was really cool. I never realized how many novels are about orphans. I actually used to make fun that in disney most princess movies or even the lion king, the protaganist generally has only 1 parent. Sleeping beauty had two but was'nt raised by them. I wonder if the reason behind all this is similar to the reason novels are orphan centric.
great expectations
I liked our in-class analysis of the title. I know we discussed the title in terms of what we want for ourselves - our basic needs and our dreams. After class, though, I thought about the title as it applies to the characters in the story. What are Pip's great expectations? He doesn't seem to have any expectations, because he is not accustomed to getting what he expects - he merely gets whatever others are willing to give him. Joe too has no great expectations, but at least he has control over his own situation - he could leave Mrs. Joe if he wanted, but he has his own reasons for not doing so. Mrs. Joe and Uncle Pumblechook have the expectation that all those around them will act in a way they approve of. Miss Havisham's expectations are morbid and desperately sad, and Estella's expectations...well, I don't know what they are yet, though perhaps I ahevm'tread far enough.
Wednesday, October 29, 2008
great expectations
great expectations makes us think about what we, as humans, want from life. what we want is normally what we expect for ourselves, but unfortunately because of social class or other stopping features, many people dont go all the way with what they expect for themselves. this is the story of pip, but hopefully, he will struggle and try to break free from this cliche. literature suggests that orphans dont always succeed in life, they are the ones who have to work harder and reach for what they want without any help. This is the type of books authors write because we like tuo read stories of hardhsips and of people who have done things on their own! hope it goes well with pip!
Pip, the orphan
I really liked todays class discussion about the orphans of the countless books out there. As I talked about it class, I believe, because of the era the Great Expectations comes from, the orphan is a tool utilized to reveal the society and culture of that period. It can display how the environment at that time created people, who are essentially products of their environment, to be from the highest of the upper class to the lowest of the low (convicts, such as in Great Expectations).
I feel really bad for Pip... this poor orphan who, from a very young age, is treated terribly by all those around him, and who desires to become a gentlemen and the heartbreak I feel for him when the readers know that such a wish would not be fulfilled in his society (which I think is felt all the more because in America, we can decide for ourselves). Poor pip! I hope he gets a happy ending (as Ive never read this story before).
I feel really bad for Pip... this poor orphan who, from a very young age, is treated terribly by all those around him, and who desires to become a gentlemen and the heartbreak I feel for him when the readers know that such a wish would not be fulfilled in his society (which I think is felt all the more because in America, we can decide for ourselves). Poor pip! I hope he gets a happy ending (as Ive never read this story before).
Great Expectations
After reading the first few chapters of the book I feel really bad for Pip. He is in a world that he doesnt want to be in, with no parents, and nothing to look forward to in life. He is constantly put down by everyone around him. Pip has dreams of being a gentleman but those are also shattered when he learns he is going to be a blacksmith like Joe. Being that he is an orphan he has no identity and is trying to find out who he is. He is possessed by a strong feeling of guilt when he helps the convict. I think that he does help the covict so that he feels like he has a purpose in life and that someone needs him.
Self -reliance
I agree with what Emerson writes about in terms of envy. It is very important for every indivisual to be themselves and to be original. He says that Envy is ignorant. This is very true. When someone gets jealous of someone else they strive and strive to get what the other person has. They always feel that the grass is always greener on the other side. By doing this they are a failure in becoming their own person and bringing out their indivisuality. They are just immitating what someone else is. One of my favorite songs, The sunscreen song, says "Dont waste your time on jealousy; sometimes youre ahead, sometimes youre behind...the race is long, and in the end its only with yourself". I think this has a lot to do with what Emerson writes on jealousy.
Tuesday, October 28, 2008
Emerson
I really enjoyed reading Emerson's Self-Reliance. He says it like it is. I think that he makes valid arguments such as: "Imitation is suicide", "Envy is ignorance" and "Trust thyself". Everyone is a conformist in some sort of way. I agree with Emerson in that conformity destroys uniqueness. But there are no two completely alike people. He says that everyone comes from a certain place and we should try to be our own person. He didn't live in today's world, where most of the things that characterize us have to do with money and materialism. Everyone tries to conform to something and trying to be a noncomformist is extremely hard in my opinion.
conformity
as we spoke in class, conformity has a huge impact on the individual, it can determine who they actually are and who they are striving to be like. conformity in America has always been at a high rate, from actions to materials, a lot of people want to be like each other and do the same thing. even when people want to stand out, that becomes the new trend and suddenly everyone wants to do the same. emerson says that conformity suppresses the role of individuality and that is 100% true, because by everyone trying to do what the other is doing, who is that actual person?
Monday, October 27, 2008
Self-Reliance
I thought this essay was very interesting. I agree with Emerson that conformity does hurt the person you are and can damage individuality. However, I also think that conformity is a slippery subject. If you do not conform to society, you are technically conforming to nonconformity. I think it's nearly impossible sometimes not to conform in certain ways. Also, sometimes people judge others as conformists when it's not necessarily true. In fact, just today my friend called me a conformist because I love the artist Monet. And as it so happens, I've loved him since I was six, before I knew he was highly popular, just from the prints hanging in my house. So conformity is not an easy subject to deal with. Technically, everyone is conforming to society's norms by attending school in clothes, aside from the fact that you can get arrested if you don't. But everyone conforms in some way. It's not a horrible thing, in small doses, but everyone should develop their own unique belief system and values, to truly appreciate their unique self.
Kubla Khan
I think that the imagination is an amazing thing. It allows us to create anything we want with no limits. This poem also talks about imagination but how it is limited once you write your thoughts down. I especially like the use of all the metaphors that were used in the poem. They give a sense of imagination and creativity. The poem shows us that having an imagination is a good thing and not something that should be frowned upon.
Kubla Khan
when i first read this poem i didn't understand it but with the class discussion made me understand it a little. it was a poem that opened up the door for many other poets. it should that poetry can show different types of themes. it showed how you can learn form life experiences and morals. but i have to say that his dream was very wierd and creepy.
Self-Reliance Essay
i very much say that this essay was very good. i think that it was saying that we are more capable of thinking and doing things. we sometimes imagine more than we do but we are able to do more than we imagine only if we try. we are so up in society in doing what good in society that we forget to do whats more imporatant to use. i really enjoy reading Self Reliance very much.
Tinturn Abbey
i found that Abbey words moved a lot of readers. Abbey used her emotions well to met depth of her words. with this emotion i was able to see the message in the poem and why it could be very touching to readers. it truely make us appreciate the finer things in life, it really was a beautiful poem.
Baudelaire - The Carcass
I have to say that i missed understood the reading before we disgusted it in class. the class discussion help me a lot. i found that baudelaire language in writing the poem was very shocking and had a beauty inherent. it was very graphic and visual.
Flowers of Evil
i found this poem very good. i thought that he used his words very beautiful to talk about the evil in us as human beings.
Self-Reliance Essay.
What an inspiration! With all of the school work that I have to do, this essay made me feel so much better about my potential as a person. I loved it when Emerson (1841) said "Trust thyself: every heart vibrates to that iron string" (p.2). We sometimes forget to that, as much as we may say it to others, and I think we are more capable of thinking and doing things than we can imagine. There is good poem by Nelson Mandela that says that we are afraid of our own greatness as human beings. We get so stuck with following norms and rules in society that we don't really pay that much attention to our real take on things, which I'd understand perfectly. We are always doing something if not for ourselves, it's for others including school, work, family, friends, etc. I enjoyed reading this essay and I can't wait to discuss it in class.
Carcass- hated and loved
The way Baudelaire put this together it can be compared to an art work, controversial , which form some of us enjoy it and some of us hated. But I think there is a third category of readers that hate the descriptive part of it in some cases and at the same time love the fact that even though it is such a nasty description and at the same it is beautiful that he is able to express love in that way. In the beginning, I sort of disliked it and was not sure what was trying to really describe but after learning that it was about love I really liked it!
In the beginning I really wasn't enjoying Carcass. I thought it was graphic and very visual. I think its hysterical how he describes a decomposing carcass. Like who picks this topic? I like the last lines how he says " that I am the keeper of the corpses of love of the form and the essence divine". He really loves someone and tries very hard to express those feelings of love. An interesting point is that he tries to portray the how natural it is for a body to decompose. It is also very natural to fall in love and to love someone. Love is a natural thing. You cant force it or prevent it. Just like when a body decomposes.
Carcass
I really liked this poem. He took what would be nothing less than just this gory vision and described it in this somewhat beautiful manner. It was explicit, allowing his readers to completely visualize this carcass the same way he did. I also liked the fact that this was very real. As we talked about it in class, people now have been spoiled compared to back in the days when it was common to see a dead body or anything we might find pretty gory today. We are constantly being kept from the ugly side of reality, which I blame no one for! Yet, I still enjoyed it!
Sunday, October 26, 2008
The Carcass
I was not disturbed by Baudelaire's descriptiveness in this poem. I actually loved the gory details, especially because they were written in such a beautiful form. Though he talks of death and decay you can't help but be enthralled by his way of describing it all. Since most people usually avoid the subject of death and don't talk about it- this poem lays down everything, in detail, for you to remember. Furthermore, i think it is just genius how though he speaks of death and decay he is really using the subject to express his love- a very complicated thing to do it seems, but done so easily by him. This poem was nothing like i have read before- i even read it to my family because i had to share it with someone.
Saturday, October 25, 2008
Carcass
Ok... First I was all about Baudelaire( and I still am...) but I am really disturbed by his chosen subject matter. I think its the marriage between the dour subject matter and the beautiful compostion is very disturbing ( but I love It!!) Who writes about a decomposing carcass. Is the carcass? To whom is Baudelaire speaking ?? I hate being confused and scared!!
Flowers of Evil...
WoW!! how heavy is this piece!!!
This is probably one of the most beautiful things I have EVER read! The writing is almost floral in its prose!! I find it almost Ironic that it is talking about the evil in all of us... Its reminds me almost of a Tintoretto painting... the beauty is in the shadows...
Friday, October 24, 2008
The Carcass
Anyone, that can write a poem about a decaying body,and actually create this disgusting visualization with his words,all because he is trying to express how much he loves someone is AMAZING! The depth of this poem is intense, which is how he must of felt when he was writing it. Everything about this poem is natural, the decaying body,maggots, worms, the dog, grass, and the love that he feels. A trully fascinating work of art, I absolutly loved it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)