Monday, September 8, 2008
the Miller's Tale
while reading the miller's tale, i was ready to be yet again amazed at the language that the author uses to describe thos story. his use of sexual innuendos is not only confusing, its funny to read these words, knowing that this is taking place years ago. it is somehow satirical as well, especially the branding on the buttox in the end, it sounds like something you would watch nowadays in a cartoon, so the author is here making light of a very dangerous situation. after going over it in class, more and more information comes out, and were digging deeper and deeper into the mind of the author, noticing he has a flare for satire and not telling the whole truth
Saturday, September 6, 2008
Canterbury Tales - The Miller's Tale
I enjoyed the Miller's Tale, and in light of the sexual themes we uncovered in class, the story seemed incredibly graphic. I think the bawdiness of the tale highlights the Miller's lower station (especially in comparison with the Knight, who gets to speak first, and the Monk, who was supposed to speak second.) When the miller insists upon speaking before the Monk, the host is quick to point out that the Monk is a better man - thought this could be a comment on the Miller's inebriation, it also seems likely to reflect the Miller's station in life.
The Miller's tale is hilarious, and though I may be digging too deep, I saw some Christian parallels in the story. Like the prologue, where Chaucer intermingles talk of love and sex with holiness, the Miller's tale has a graphic love story (where Nicholas grabs Alison, thereby seducing her, and they have sex in her husband's bed) and also a Bible parallel (where Nicholas acts as God, commanding John to prepare for the flood, and Absalom acts as Satan, with a fiery brand).
I also thought it was interesting that Absalom - the courteous suitor, who courts properly - is rudely rejected, while Nicholas, the skeevy guy who puts his hands on Alison until she threatens to scream for help, manages to get the girl. What is Chaucer trying to say about love, and about sexuality? Chaucer does not condemn Alison's adultery - and in fact, the story ends with Alison and Nicholas together and John, suffering and ridiculed. Is it because Chaucer is trying to be super radical and challenge the Christian idea that sex should only happen within the bonds of marriage? Or is it because the Miller is narrating and his low-class ideals are shining through his tale? It's pretty clear that the Miller thinks John was stupid for marrying a girl so much younger and prettier, but does that make it okay for Alison to cheat?
Even without looking into the details of the story, the tale seems somewhat Biblical. The story is about a carpenter and his wife...possibly a parallel to Joseph and Mary, since Joseph was also a carpenter. That seems weird to me (and obviously heretical) because if Mary is supposed to parallel Alison then it seems like Chaucer is implying that Mary's "conception" was not immaculate, and actually came from an adulterous relationship. That would make Jesus a bastard and not the son of God, which seems completely inappropriate for Chaucer to have written in his time. How on earth did he get away with writing the Canterbury Tales?!
The Miller's tale is hilarious, and though I may be digging too deep, I saw some Christian parallels in the story. Like the prologue, where Chaucer intermingles talk of love and sex with holiness, the Miller's tale has a graphic love story (where Nicholas grabs Alison, thereby seducing her, and they have sex in her husband's bed) and also a Bible parallel (where Nicholas acts as God, commanding John to prepare for the flood, and Absalom acts as Satan, with a fiery brand).
I also thought it was interesting that Absalom - the courteous suitor, who courts properly - is rudely rejected, while Nicholas, the skeevy guy who puts his hands on Alison until she threatens to scream for help, manages to get the girl. What is Chaucer trying to say about love, and about sexuality? Chaucer does not condemn Alison's adultery - and in fact, the story ends with Alison and Nicholas together and John, suffering and ridiculed. Is it because Chaucer is trying to be super radical and challenge the Christian idea that sex should only happen within the bonds of marriage? Or is it because the Miller is narrating and his low-class ideals are shining through his tale? It's pretty clear that the Miller thinks John was stupid for marrying a girl so much younger and prettier, but does that make it okay for Alison to cheat?
Even without looking into the details of the story, the tale seems somewhat Biblical. The story is about a carpenter and his wife...possibly a parallel to Joseph and Mary, since Joseph was also a carpenter. That seems weird to me (and obviously heretical) because if Mary is supposed to parallel Alison then it seems like Chaucer is implying that Mary's "conception" was not immaculate, and actually came from an adulterous relationship. That would make Jesus a bastard and not the son of God, which seems completely inappropriate for Chaucer to have written in his time. How on earth did he get away with writing the Canterbury Tales?!
Friday, September 5, 2008
Canterbury Tales
Just like some others in class, it is my first time reading the Canterbury Tales. I enjoyed reading the prologue and thought it was pleasant, funny, and very enjoyable to learn about the different characters that are along for the journey. However, I failed to read so closely as to identify the possible underlying meanings behind Chaucer's words, as we did in class. I look forward to continuing our discussion in class and to discovering new interpretations.
Canterbury Tales Reflections: The Prologue
Chaucer's novel is written in a poetic narrative. The advantages of this style is that Chaucer can add, criticize and respond to societal issues in a subtle manner. When reading Chaucer's Prologue, each read reveals more information and more content value. I think by using this method Chaucer adds more value and interest to the book. He presents the characters, all different parts of society. By looking closely different aspects of society,at this time are revealed. I enjoy the fact that there is deeper meaning to the Canterbury Tales.
Canterbury Tales
I remember doing part of Canterbury Tales in High School but I was kind of bored with it then. However, when we were in class and our eyes were opened to the sexual connotations in the writing I found that very interesting. It's very cool how you could read something one time, and then after reading between the lines see the same text in two completely different lights. I'm looking forward to seeing what else I did not notice about each of the characters the first time.
Wednesday, September 3, 2008
Canterbury Tales
Chaucer's Canterbury Tales seems very real to me. I feel as though I can relate to the characters. I like the rhythmic tone the author uses. It allows the story to flow. When reading it before today's class, I just read the introductory paragraph without actually taking apart each sentence. After being introduced to the different meaning of what Chaucer is writing, I think that from now on, I will start to try and interpret other books I read. I liked the depiction of each character who is joining the narrator on the pilgrimage. The way Chaucer portrays the characters is very descriptive.
After first reading the prologue in Canterbury Tales, it was interesting to meet all these new characters, some who fit certain stereotypes and some who are just coming in as odd. the set up by the hotel host is interesting because who knows what kind of stories these people can come up with, and seeing how we dug so deep into each word today inclass, i can tell that we are going to find out many more secrets in the tales.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)