Monday, December 22, 2008
Spring is in the air....Miller's Tale
Spring is in the air apparently in Miller's tale. First of all, I don't think I will ever look at the word "spring" the same way again. Who knew that is was all about "piercing the root of March" in the prologue. As for the tale, at first Allison struck me as the immoral player but after our in class discussion, I actually felt bad for her (somewhat). While it is wrong to not only cheat on your husband but to deceive him to the extent that she did, she did not deserve to be with someone whom she did not love. I believe that Chaucer in this tale and others presents a flip side to what society would view as moral and immoral. Reading his tales allows us to not see situations in just black and white as I have also viewed John in different ways...sympathetic yet stupid.
Sunday, December 21, 2008
Pardoner: definitely bad....but is he also good?
The Pardoner was also pretty interesting. The Pardoner is one of the worst sinners in Chaucer's tales. One of his lines is, "and lo, sirs, thus I preach. And Jesus Christ, that is our souls' leech, So grant you his pardon to receive, For that is best, I will you not deceive", would have anyone to think that he is after forgiveness and is therefore true to his words. Unfortunately, this is just one of his ploys to suck people into his schemes. The fact that he is aware of what's right and what's wrong and uses Jesus Christ's name in order to deceive others makes him one of the worst sinners. Or is this a way of him wanting forgiveness? When he tells the tale of greed and shows how money can be the root of all evil, it gives the sense of him not just out to hurt others but to warn them of evil. One who is completely evil would not try to warn another of self-destruction. Atleast, I don't think so.
Wife Of Bath
The Wife of Bath was one of my favorite Chaucer tales. "Authority vs. Experience" is the argument for who the Wife of Bath is. She challenges the church's authority and what is acceptable behavior from a woman. While the church might have viewed her five marriages as distasteful and contrary to sacred values, she made the conscious decision of living her life through experience. She made a good point about how the church makes up these rules on marriage yet, for the most part...no nothing of the subject at hand. While it is important to obtain and practice one's values, it is also important to follow your heart and make your own experiences to live and learn from...as what the Wife of Bath did.
While I also enjoyed the tale of the man's journey, I did not feel one bit sorry for him. I don't think it was fair for him to have done what he did, and in the end get to spend his life with a beautiful and loyal wife. I wonder if in those days, how different would it have been for a woman who did something just as worst.
While I also enjoyed the tale of the man's journey, I did not feel one bit sorry for him. I don't think it was fair for him to have done what he did, and in the end get to spend his life with a beautiful and loyal wife. I wonder if in those days, how different would it have been for a woman who did something just as worst.
Carcass
Since I have been mentioning alot about love I felt it appropriate to end off with Baudelaire's poem Carcass. When I first read through this poem I didn't catch that it was meant to be romantic. I know that the person was not comparing the looks of the carcass to his girlfriend or vice versa but it is a very peculiar way to declare your love for someone. It is nice to see that he truly loves his companion but the way in which he went through the description of this carcass to finally tell her was very interesting. I don't think this type of poem would work to win me over. But we must give him credit for doing so in an unorthodox way.
Love = Desire, Desire =Love
I know we were assigned specific poems from Coleridge but I looked up some of his other poems and came across this verse in his poem Desire, "Where true Love burns Desire is Love's pure flame". I think this quote is very profound. I think it explains love in a very enticing and attractive manner. Many people think love is lust but it is not. Lust is more of a craving that is temporary while desire is more of a strong wish which will not go away if true love is in the equation. I think people can lust for something without loving it but you must love something in order to desire and vice versa.
Good vs. Evil
"There is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so" ( Hamlet Act II Sc. II) In saying this Hamlet is giving us an insight into life. Is this statement true? Can there really exist no wrong or right way? Why is it that there are actions or sayings that are proper for some and improper for others? I think it is amazing how common we are as humans in a biological and microscopic level. We all have the same basic needs, we need food, shelter, warmth and water. However, we are all unique and unlike anyone else. But how is it that some things offend some people but not others? How did we get to this point of difference? I think this is a very intriguing quotes because in the end what defines an act or saying as being a bad or good one depends on our definition in life. This reminds me of Emerson because in his essay he says not to be a comformist and to speak whatever it is that we feel we must not worrying about what others say. But should we not respect others space? Shouldn't we try to make others feel comfortable and not say hurtful things to others? Life is full of questions but we all have our own answers to it.
Where art thou Hamlet????
I think Hamlet's story is a very unfortunate and sad one. He seemed like he was a smart guy that could have made better choices but I guess we all cope with things differently. But Hamlet's most famous quote "To be, or not to be:that is the question" (Act III Sc I) is still one of the questions that it most pondered about. I also think it puts human existence into perspective and my interpretation of that quote is what is our role here on earth. What is our calling??? Now I know you can not answer a question with another question but if I had to rephrase Hamlet's question, that would be my attempt. It is really hard to answer Hamlet's question in life sometimes because we spend most of our life trying to seek that which we must be here on earth. I think some people spend their whole life trying to find out who they truly are or must become. They search for their main duty here on this planet. But in the end it is our choice to be or not to be............but what is the the right answer to that question?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)